PDA

View Full Version : SPPF Superlative Manga Voting Thread



Atari
24th March 2006, 9:46 PM
Approved by Brinstar on March 23, 2006

Hello everyone, and welcome to the SPPf Superlative Manga Voting Thread. Here is the one place you may freely post your favorite manga from a selection of different genres, including:

Best comedy
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo)
Best artistic/alternative
Best original art in any book
Best storyline
Best action/adventure
Best fighting
Best science fiction
Best historical
Best horror

Rules
1. Only one ballot per person.

EDIT: -
EDIT2: -
EDIT3: April 25, 2006

Mimori Kiryu
24th March 2006, 9:55 PM
Sounds interesting. Let's have some fun:

Best Comedy: Fooly Cooly (FLCL)
Best Romance/Fantasy: Fushigi Yuugi
Best Artistic/Alternative: Do you mean best art? If you do, then Fullmetal Alchemist
Best Original Art In Any Book: s-CRY-ed/Scryed
Best Storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best Action/Adventure: Saiyuki
Best Fighting: Hellsing
Best Science Fiction: Chobits (well, computers right? >>)
Best Historical: Samurai Champloo. If not, Rurouni Kenshin.
Best Horror: Hellsing

w00t. ^^

Skiks
24th March 2006, 10:17 PM
Best comedy:Bleach
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo):Full Moon wo Sagashite (Gah haven't read that many)
Best original art in any book:Trigun
Best storyline:Full Metal Alchemist (Haven't gotten that into Trigun to make much of a judgement or hellsing for that matter)
Best action/adventure:As in shonen? Then One Piece (Hunter X Hunter does have a lot of down time when it comes to action. Besides another series deserves a shot)
Best fighting:Hunter X Hunter
Best historical:Ruroni Kenshin
Best horror:Hellsing
Done and done.

Minami Itsuki
25th March 2006, 1:55 AM
Best comedy: Slam Dunk
Best romance/fantasy(Shoujo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Full Metal Alchemist
Best original art in any book: Oh! My Goddess
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure: Saiyuki
Best fighting: Hajime no Ippo
Best science fiction: Vandread
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: Hellsing

Done. ^^

Kokukirin
25th March 2006, 2:08 AM
Best comedy - Level E
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo) - RG Veda
Best artistic/alternative - Vagabond
Best original art in any book - Vagabond
Best storyline - Monster
Best action/adventure - Hunter x Hunter
Best fighting - Yu Yu Hakusho
Best science fiction - Legend of the Galactic Heroes
Best historical - Peacemaker Kurogane
Best horror - Tomie

Juputoru
25th March 2006, 4:08 PM
Best comedy - Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo) - Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative - Detective Conan (Not sure exactly where a detective series would go, and this seems to be the vaguest catagory, so...)
Best storyline - Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure - Bleach
Best fighting - Shaman King
Best historical - Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror - Hellsing

That Scary Clefairy
25th March 2006, 6:23 PM
Best comedy: School Rumble - just read it and Its so hilarious, especially Harima Kenji

Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Angel Sanctuary

Best artistic/alternative: Trinity Blood ( I know its a novel but damn have you ever seen the illustrations for the novel? Its ****ing awesome!)

Best original art in any book: Hellsing (this is where Hellsing's cataglory should be classified in.)

Best storyline:Berserk hands down

Best action/adventure:Trigun Maximum

Best fighting:Bleach (I just like Bleach. I'm sure there is a better fighting series out there but this is all I can think of at the moment.)

Best science fiction: Blame! (Able to tell a story with minimum amount of words)

Best historical:Rurouni Kenshin definetly.

Best horror: Uzumaki (Hellsing is not really classified as Horror despite its vampire characters.)

any comment or compliant on my list or what I said, pm me since you can't post twice here. :rolleyes:

The Red Butterfly
25th March 2006, 9:40 PM
Best comedy :
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative:Fruits Basket
Best original art in any book: Case Closed
Best storyline:Fruits Basket
Best action/adventure:Case Closed
Best fighting: Yu Yu Hakusho
Best science fiction:
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror:

Atari
27th March 2006, 12:34 AM
Well, it doesn't look like to many people are interested in voting... So, here's my vote I guess:

Best comedy: Midori Days(Midori no Hibi)
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): DNAngel
Best artistic/alternative: Comic Party
Best original art in any book: ARIA
Best storyline: Full Metal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: Zatch Bell
Best fighting: Realbout High School
Best science fiction: Cowboy Behop
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: (blank)

Wandering Rhythmical Phoenix
27th March 2006, 1:02 AM
Best comedy: BoBo-Bo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Descendants Of Darkness
Best artistic/alternative:
Best original art in any book: Get Backers
Best storyline: FullMetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: Beet The Vandel Buster
Best fighting: Rave Master
Best science fiction
Best historical:Ruron Ken
Best horror

Brinstar
27th March 2006, 1:54 AM
Best comedy - Cromartie High School
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo) - Fruits Basket
Best original art in any book - Samurai Champloo
Best storyline - Naruto
Best action/adventure - One Piece
Best fighting - Naruto
Best science fiction - Trigun Maximum
Best historical - Rurouni Kenshin

Megchan
27th March 2006, 2:31 AM
Best comedy: Ranma 1/2
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Furuba aka Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best original art in any book: N/A
Best storyline: Alice 19th
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Bleach
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: N/A

Kecleon Freak
29th March 2006, 1:16 AM
Best comedy-Bobobo-Bo Bo-bobo
Best storyline-Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure-One Piece
Best fighting-One Piece
Best historical-Rurouni Kenshin

HK
31st March 2006, 1:25 AM
lol this went nowhere

Kanta-chan
31st March 2006, 1:51 AM
Best comedy-- N/A
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo)-- Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative-- Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
Best original art in any book-- Cardcaptor Sakura
Best storyline-- Chrono Crusade: Mary Magdalene
Best action/adventure-- Bleach
Best fighting-- Naruto
Best science fiction-- N/A
Best historical-- N/A
Best horror-- N/A

Road
14th April 2006, 9:19 PM
I don't read much manga, but...

Best comedy: Zatch Bell
Best romance/fantasy: N/A
Best artistic/alternative: Tenchi Muyo
Best original art in any book: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best storyline: Zatch Bell
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Naruto
Best historical: Yu-Gi-Oh!
Best horror: N/A

That's all I got. x_x

SugarFairy
14th April 2006, 11:14 PM
I havent read very much Mangas.. But that means I cant vote =3

Best comedy: Azumanga Daioh
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Mink
Best artistic/alternative: CardCaptor Sakura
Best action/adventure: Full Metal Alchemist
Best science fiction: Tokyo Mew Mew (it said it was Science Fiction)

Satoshi
14th April 2006, 11:24 PM
Best comedy: BoBoBo-Bo Bo-BoBo (Only manga I read that mainly focuses on comedy, would've voted for Bleach if I didn't read this.)
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle
Best original art in any book: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best storyline: Hagane no Renkin Jutsushi (Fullmetal Alchemist)
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: .Hack//黄昏の腕輪伝説 (Tasogare no Udewa Densetsu) (Legend of The Twilight Bracelet)
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: N/A

Tenten
14th April 2006, 11:29 PM
Best comedy: BoBoBo-Bobo-BoBo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best original art in any book: xxxHolic
Best storyline: Hikaru no Go
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Bleach
Best science fiction: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: Uzumaki, hands down!

>__> I haven't read too many manga, so don't blame me for not being "original" here...

Korobooshi Kojiro
26th April 2006, 12:16 AM
Best comedy: BoBoBo
Best original art in any book: Hikaru no Go
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Eyeshield 21 (Does footbal count as fighting?)
Best science fiction: Sgt Frog
Best historical: Rorouni Kenshin
Best horror: Deathnote

Atari
26th April 2006, 3:54 AM
Reminder: Look, I don't know about the ballot counting, but I can't do it tonight. I feel like an idiot for keeping it up for longer than expected, but now it seems like it should stay up longer. If anybody has any input/help count votes, anything will be appriciated. Voting is currently open.

Solar Crimson
22nd May 2006, 12:44 AM
Best comedy- Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo)- Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative-
Best original art in any book- Hikaru no Go
Best storyline- One Piece
Best action/adventure- Hunter x Hunter
Best fighting- D. Gray-man
Best science fiction- D. Gray-man
Best historical-
Best horror- [Death Note[/i]

Hakajin
28th June 2006, 3:07 AM
Best comedy- Azumanga Daioh
Best Romance/Fantasy (Shoujo)- MeruPuri
Best Artistitc/Alternative- Do downloads count? If so, then Music of Marie. If not, Lament of the Lamb
Best Original Art- Fuguruma Memories of Lament of the Lamb
Best Storyline- Again, downloads? Music of Marie or Inu-Yasha
Best Science Fiction- Chobits
Best Horror- Uzumaki

Goth_Guy
11th July 2006, 2:18 AM
Best comedy: Ranma 1/2
Best romance: Marmalade Boy
Best artistic/alternative: Pokemn Special/ Pokemon Adventures
Best original art in any book: Chobits
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure : Naruto
Best fighting : Cowboy Bebop
Best science fiction : Galaxy Angel
Best historical : Inu-Yasha (Time Travel)
Best horror : the manga remake of William Peter Blatty's Novel "The Exorcist"

Kirsty_
2nd August 2006, 6:46 PM
Best comedy: Love Hina
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Fruits Basket
Best original art in any book: -
Best storyline: Fruits Basket
Best action/adventure: InuYasha
Best fighting: InuYasha
Best science fiction: Chobits
Best historical: -
Best horror: Hellsing

Super-Staff
4th November 2006, 8:01 PM
Best comedy - Bobobo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo) - Sailor Moon
Best artistic/alternative - Shaman King
Best original art in any book- One Piece (for shonen) and Fruits Basket (for shoujo)
Best storyline - Full Metal Alchemist
Best action/adventure - One Piece
Best fighting - Bleach
Best science fiction - Black Cat
Best historical - Samurai Champloo
Best horror - Hellsing

umbreloom
15th January 2007, 1:47 AM
Best comedy : Bobobo!
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Ichigo 100%
Best storyline:Naruto
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Dbz
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror:Death Note

Aika
17th March 2007, 12:38 PM
Best comedy: Fruits Basket.
Best Romance/Fantasy: Tricky, but Fruits Basket again.
Best artistic: Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle.
Best original art: Full Moon wo Sagashite.
Best storyline: Fruits Basket.
Best action/adventure: Naruto.
Best fighting: Full Metal Alchemist.
Best Science Fiction: Chobits.
Best Historical: N/A
Best Horror: N/A

Tsubasa
31st March 2007, 5:37 AM
Best comedy: Ouran High School Host Club (It's hilarious)
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Gunslinger Girl
Best original art in any book: Gunslinger Girl
Best storyline: Bleach
Best action/adventure: Hunter X Hunter
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Gundam Ecole du Ciel
Best historical: N/A
Best horror: The Ring

honey_clover112
13th June 2007, 2:45 PM
Best comedy: Ranma 1/2
Best romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best original art in any book: XXXHolic
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure : Naruto
Best fighting : Full Metal Alchemist
Best science fiction : Galaxy Angel
Best historical : Samurai X
Best horror : HellSing

;006;

Outlawz
9th July 2007, 5:11 AM
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best Romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best Original Art: Hellsing
Best Storyline: Berserk
Best Action/Adventure: One Piece
Best Fighting: Bleach(Even though nobody ever dies, the fights are still fun to watch)
Best SciFi: N/A
Best Historical: N/A
Best Horror:Hellsing, This was tough it was between either Hellsing or Death Note. I mean Hellsing has the blood an vampires, but can you think of anything scarier than a killer notebook? But, Death Note is more psychological so I give it to Hellsing.

Anzua2
9th July 2007, 5:32 AM
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best Romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best Original Art: One Piece
Best Storyline: One Piece
Best Action/Adventure: One Piece
Best Fighting: Bleach
Best Horror:Hellsing

Namikaze
24th February 2008, 12:58 AM
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best fighting: Naruto
Best Action/Adventure: Bleach
Best Horror: Hellsing

Nuriko55020
2nd March 2008, 8:07 AM
Best comedy:Naruto
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo):Fushigi Yugi
Best artistic/alternative:Naruto
Best original art in any book:Fruit Basket
Best storyline:Naruto
Best action/adventure:Naruto
Best fighting:Naruto
Best science fiction:Fushigi Yugi
Best historical:Fushigi Yugi
Best horror:Naruto
Mostly Naruto.

ak47madden
25th December 2008, 1:13 AM
Best comedy: Not many mangas focus on comedy but If I had to pick it would be Bleach
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Lol N/A
Best artistic/alternative: Vagabond
Best original art in any book: Berserk
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Gantz
Best historical: Berserk
Best horror: Berserk

Edward_Elric
30th January 2009, 3:30 AM
Best Comedy: AzuManga
Best Romance/Fantasy: ...
Best Artistic/Alternative: ...
Best Original Art In Any Book: .Hack G.U.+
Best Storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best Action/Adventure: s-CRY-ed
Best Fighting: Bleach
Best Science Fiction: .Hack and the Legend of the Twilight Bracelet
Best Historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best Horror: The Drifting Classroom

Sailor Girl91
27th July 2009, 1:06 AM
Best Comedy:The Wallflower
Best Romance:Sailor Moon
Best artistic: Rozen Maiden
Best Original Art:Pita Ten
Best Storyline:Tokyo Mew Mew
Best Action/Adventure:Shaman King
Best fighting:Shaman King
Bset science fiction:Chobits
Best Historical:(none)
Best Horror:Death Note

MapleRoses
15th August 2009, 8:35 AM
Best comedy- Crayon Sinchan <- is this counted as a manga?
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo)
- Hana Yori Dango
Best artistic/alternative
- Oh My Goddess
Best original art in any book
- Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best storyline
- Bleach
Best action/adventure
- Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best fighting-
Inuyasha
Best science fiction-
Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best historical
N/A
Best horror
Death Note

Cutty
3rd September 2009, 5:43 PM
Best comedy- Crayon shinchan
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo)- Candy candy
Best artistic/alternative- Death Note
Best original art in any book- Yugi-Oh!
Best storyline- I like GTO
Best action/adventure- Shoot me, One Piece (I can list LOTS of others if I want, really).
Best fighting- Tomorrow's Joe
Best science fiction- Blame! (more b/c I dont understand it)
Best historical- Sanzoku Ou, maybe.
Best horror- Le Portrait de Petit Cossette

Do I sound old?

ShinyPichu4Ever
3rd December 2009, 11:22 AM
Best comedy: Ouran High School Host Club
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Cardcaptor Sakura, XXXholic, and Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles sequence (yes they are all corelated so I put them together)
Best original art in any book: FullMetal Alchemist or One Piece
Best storyline: FullMetal Alchemist or Soul Eater
Best action/adventure: FullMetal Alchemist
Best fighting: FullMetal Alchemist or Katekyo Hitman Reborn
Best science fiction: FullMetal Alchemist

Lorde
18th January 2010, 8:36 PM
Here is my ballot:

Best comedy: Fooly Cooly
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best original art in any book: Death Note
Best storyline: Fullmetal Achemist
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Yu Yu Hakusho
Best science fiction: Vandread
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin.
Best horror : Hellsing

DarkMagician12
25th October 2010, 11:44 AM
Best comedy : Fullmetal alchemist
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) : Full Moon Wo Sagashite
Best artistic/alternative *
Best original art in any book: Death Note
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: (I suppose this is under it) D Gray Man
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction:*
Best historical: *
Best horror: *

* I haven't read any manga which is under those genre.

akon1089
24th December 2010, 8:40 AM
Best comedy: BoBoBo
Best original art in any book: Hikaru no Go
Best storyline: Heat Pad (http://www.shantinathsales.com/product/heat-pad/6/) Naruto
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Eyeshield 21 (Does footbal count as fighting?)
Best science fiction: Sgt Frog
Best historical: Rorouni Kenshin
Best horror: Deathnote

ya this is absolutely correct....

weirdamanda
19th January 2011, 7:34 AM
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Fruitsbasket
Best original art in any book: FMA
Best storyline: FMA
Best fighting: Yu Yu Hakusho
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin, Yu-Gi-Oh Millenium World as a close second
Best horror: Deathnote

Jinchuuriki Hunter
4th March 2011, 1:59 PM
...huh...I wonder if I've read/watched enough to vote here...

Best comedy: Fooly Cooly
Best romance/fantasy: Ouran High School Host Club I guess? Haven't read much shoujo.
Best artistic/alternative: Bakuman
Best original art in any book: Soul Eater
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: One Piece by far
Best fighting: Jojo's Bizare Adventure by far
Best science fiction: ...Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann? That's the closest thing to sci-fi I've ever read/watched and it's awesome.
Best historical: eh...
Best horror: Who in their right minds would watch something just to scare themselves? That's just something I don't understand...

roomA2
11th December 2011, 9:40 PM
Approved by Brinstar on March 23, 2006

Hello everyone, and welcome to the SPPf Superlative Manga Voting Thread. Here is the one place you may freely post your favorite manga from a selection of different genres, including:

Best comedy: Mr Slump
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) Tsubasa
Best artistic/alternative Pokemon Yellow
Best original art in any book Megaman X
Best storyline Deathnote
Best action/adventure Bleach
Best fighting Dragon Ball Z
Best science fiction Dragon Ball Z
Best historical Gosick
Best horror D- Gray Man

Rules
1. Only one ballot per person.

EDIT: -
EDIT2: -
EDIT3: April 25, 2006

Thats all I can think of throughout my history of reading manga.

Synthesia
20th December 2011, 11:04 PM
Best comedy - Fullmetal Alchemist (the extras at the end) and Hetalia: Axis Powers!
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) - Kaichou wa Maid-sama, I guess. I haven't read many romance mangas ... Code Geass if that counts!
Best artistic/alternative - (?)
Best original art in any book - Code Geass
Best storyline - Fullmetal Alchemist
Best historical - Hetalia (XD)

Galux
26th May 2012, 12:03 PM
Best comedy: Dragonball
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Cardcaptor Sakura
Best artistic/alternative: ?
Best original art in any book:?
Best storyline: Bakuman
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Dragonball Z
Best science fiction: Akira
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: ?

~Kurou
10th February 2013, 5:25 PM
Best comedy Bakuman
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) Cage of Eden
Best original art in any book One Piece
Best storyline Bleach
Best action/adventure Naruto
Best fighting Dragonball Z