SPPF Superlative Manga Voting Thread

[Charmed]

Here is my ballot:

Best comedy: Fooly Cooly
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Cardcaptor Sakura
Best original art in any book: Death Note
Best storyline: Fullmetal Achemist
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Yu Yu Hakusho
Best science fiction: Vandread
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin.
Best horror : Hellsing

[DarkMagician12]

Best comedy : Fullmetal alchemist
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) : Full Moon Wo Sagashite
Best artistic/alternative *
Best original art in any book: Death Note
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: (I suppose this is under it) D Gray Man
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction:*
Best historical: *
Best horror: *

* I haven't read any manga which is under those genre.

[akon1089]

Best comedy: BoBoBo
Best original art in any book: Hikaru no Go
Best storyline: Heat Pad Naruto
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Eyeshield 21 (Does footbal count as fighting?)
Best science fiction: Sgt Frog
Best historical: Rorouni Kenshin
Best horror: Deathnote

ya this is absolutely correct....

[weirdamanda]

Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Fruitsbasket
Best original art in any book: FMA
Best storyline: FMA
Best fighting: Yu Yu Hakusho
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin, Yu-Gi-Oh Millenium World as a close second
Best horror: Deathnote

[Jinchuuriki Hunter]

...huh...I wonder if I've read/watched enough to vote here...

Best comedy: Fooly Cooly
Best romance/fantasy: Ouran High School Host Club I guess? Haven't read much shoujo.
Best artistic/alternative: Bakuman
Best original art in any book: Soul Eater
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure: One Piece by far
Best fighting: Jojo's Bizare Adventure by far
Best science fiction: ...Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann? That's the closest thing to sci-fi I've ever read/watched and it's awesome.
Best historical: eh...
Best horror: Who in their right minds would watch something just to scare themselves? That's just something I don't understand...

[roomA2]

Approved by Brinstar on March 23, 2006

Hello everyone, and welcome to the SPPf Superlative Manga Voting Thread. Here is the one place you may freely post your favorite manga from a selection of different genres, including:

Best comedy: Mr Slump
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) Tsubasa
Best artistic/alternative Pokemon Yellow
Best original art in any book Megaman X
Best storyline Deathnote
Best action/adventure Bleach
Best fighting Dragon Ball Z
Best science fiction Dragon Ball Z
Best historical Gosick
Best horror D- Gray Man

Rules
1. Only one ballot per person.

EDIT: -
EDIT2: -
EDIT3: April 25, 2006

Thats all I can think of throughout my history of reading manga.

[Synthesia]

Best comedy - Fullmetal Alchemist (the extras at the end) and Hetalia: Axis Powers!
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) - Kaichou wa Maid-sama, I guess. I haven't read many romance mangas ... Code Geass if that counts!
Best artistic/alternative - (?)
Best original art in any book - Code Geass
Best storyline - Fullmetal Alchemist
Best historical - Hetalia (XD)

[Galux]

Best comedy: Dragonball
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Cardcaptor Sakura
Best artistic/alternative: ?
Best original art in any book:?
Best storyline: Bakuman
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Dragonball Z
Best science fiction: Akira
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror: ?

[wadder2]

Best comedy Bakuman
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo) Cage of Eden
Best original art in any book One Piece
Best storyline Bleach
Best action/adventure Naruto
Best fighting Dragonball Z