Sorry but your method is not user friendly. 8 times out of 10, when people are looking for a trade, they are looking for specific Pokémon and this is what this is set to go for. Having it by Members would make things a LOT more difficult for anyone to find what they want at all

You dont have to post in like 100 different topics. Have some restraint. People doing that would be classed as spammers

They may get spammed a bit yes, but that'll just be a small fraction of the spam, bumping etc that was going on in the previous trade forum

And believe it or not, people are a lot smarter than you give them credit for. They will look beyond the first page

This is the best and most logical system and thats that