I am wondering will it evole and see james again.
I think that Jamed do not needed to give Cacnea, because he could learning him the attack itself!!
Wobbuffet and his trainer.(credit: Serebii.net)
I thought this was the best Battle Dimension episode so far. The episode was nice and quite touching. Cacnea and James had huge character development and the story did not head the way I had thought, even though the conclusion was the same.
I'll always miss cacnea.
Ash's team right now
If you think the Sinnoh saga has been the best saga of the whole show, copy and paste this into your signature! (started by FlameRose)
If you deny any sort of existence of Iris's hair, put this into your sig (started by 5ilVer)
I thought this was a pretty good episode, episodes like these is what makes James more interesting.
I noticed alot of firsts in this episode too:
First time a villian given a Pokemon to any of the good guys (Lickitung doesn't count since it was an accident).
First time Jessie or James have actually gave thier Pokemon special training to learn a move
Plus first time a Gym leader has appeared like ten episodes before her Gym match and then ten or so episodes AFTER the Gym battle, not even Clair has reappeared way after the gym battle (Luckily I like Gardenia so I don't mind).
I do wonder of Cacnea will evovle, maybe we will somehow see him one day, Gardenia doesn't seem to always stay in her town (Eterna Forest then somewhere in Hearthome right?). Which speaking of I think still to this day Gardenia has a quite unqiue personality (But when I see Candice/Fantina/Volkner then that might change but as it stands Gardenia is the one)
Last edited by Willow's Tara; 13th November 2009 at 6:57 AM.
You stalking my posts Kira:P JK lol, are you watching from S1-11? (That's what I been doing).
I don't think it's too weird James did that, he always had that soft side, it's Jessie I don't see giving any of her Pokemon for unless it's exchange for a better one (I don't think she would have exchanged Seviper/Dustox though)
I feel bad for James and if he ever got it back (doubt it, unfortunately) it would most likely be a Cacturne, or at least Cacnea with an awesome moveset.
I truly LOVED this episode. James HAS given up 3 of his Pokes, but that's just what makes it more interesting! I do miss Cacnea though, and the Carnivine skull-bite isn't as funny as the spike-hug.
Gardenia wanted Cacnea SOOO bad! lol I'm glad she finally got it. I actually felt kind of bad for James but it would be better off with her. Great episode.
It was a nice episode. It's always fun to see the bad guys doing some good things.
Bye, Cacnea !
Sort of skipping one review to come to this episode, but I'm going to refer to that episode when writing this review as I definitely think that to fully appreciate this episode, you need to watch the last episode in the same sitting.
Both episodes are similar in that they are told from a point of view that is a little different than what we are normally used to. Last episode, Chimchar's thoughts were shown, and this episode is predominately from James's perspective, with a little of Gardenia's thought process thrown in during the double battle. I was sort of thinking of this pt when I was watching today's Sinnoh League episode b/c you can apply this there as well, but if you did not know that the show's main character was Ash, this would be a misleading episode for your first one. Yet, I think Ash is the one who gives this episode the ability to really touch the heart, just by his facial expressions. One of the pts I'm trying to show when doing these reviews is that many times the writers don't allow us to see Sinnoh Ash's thoughts, which for me highlights his maturity (I do realize I'm stretching things here, since the writers really only want us to see James's thoughts in this episode-please bear with me). So remember how last episode ends, with Ash having a satisfied, confident smile as he succeeds in helping Chimchar overcome its fears of the Zangoose (I call it Ash's "Goku" smile).
I'm not sure if this is dubbing thing or not, but it's funny how this episode starts. Brock talks about destiny in his flirting scene with Gardenia, and Jessie talks about how never giving up is a virtue during her wisecrack talking to Dawn. Really, these issues are what this episode focuses on. James does not want to give Cacnea to Gardenia, but he feels this might be what is best for the pokemon. So he basically gives himself this challenge: if he can teach Cacnea to master Drain Punch, then he is a worthy trainer for Cacnea. Gardenia plants this idea in James's mind during the double battle, and again I find it scary the way she does so. She stops paying attention to her Turtwig during the double battle, preferring to gauge Cacnea's abilities. Then after the battle she requests Cacnea from James, but does not allow him to give a response as she jumps at the opportunity the children give her to leave (acting like everything is peachy in doing so). Jessie is right, Gardenia does have an ego, and as I said before, people like that who are not what they appear to be scare me. The gym leader really plays on James's nature here.
So James accepts the challenge of teaching Cacnea drain punch, and Ash, with a smile,volunteers to do some special training with him. Again, keep in mind with what Ash has been able to do with Chimchar last episode.
Well, the training does not go so well, as James cannot get down the timing for Drain Punch. It's sunset now, and a very sad James is sitting with Cacnea off to the side while the rest of the group watches him. This is where the never giving up vs. destiny part comes him. James can feel it, that he has failed and he is going to have to give Cacnea to Gardenia for its own good. And yet, one more time, one more chance....He does not give up just yet. In a sudden burst of optimism, he calls to Ash for help, and Ash, again with a smile, agrees. Gardenia arrives to watch, to James's annoyance (and watching this, you can feel "destiny" approaching), but he consents to let her watch. So we end this episode with the battle we started it with: Cacnea vs Aipom.
Maybe Drain Punch hasn't worked that well for James, but it's obvious that his training hasn't been for nothing: Needle Arm is much stronger than it was before. And yet, that's not it. Needle Arm wasn't the pt; it has to be Drain Punch, or nothing. You can feel it; this is like Paul's problem with Chimchar. Flamethrower may have become stronger, but it must be Blaze. Nothing else will suffice. But while that conflict made you happy when Paul finally released Chimchar since you felt the right thing was going to happen, here I was tearing up. Cacnea is not going to master Drain Punch, and James is going to have to release it. This is destiny, as Cynthia later says about Chimchar and its relation to Ash and Paul, but...it's so different, isn't it? And James and Cacnea still try to run away from it, try to never give up. But Focus punch after focus punch lands on Cacnea, and it's heartbreaking. Ash has gone from smiling to clenching his teeth (maybe even close to crying himself).
James finally grabs Cacnea and tells it to stop. He gives Cacnea to Gardenia, acknowledging that he knows she will take care of it (which is what this whole episode was about, right?). And off he runs, with Gardenia turning her face to Cacnea's pokeball as Jessie and Meowth follow. Ash and company watch as well, in silence with serious, sympathetic looks on their faces. It's an amazing scene, and definitely when you compare it was the look on Ash's face at the end of last episode, it really just hits you what has happened in this episode. Sometimes life has feel good stories like last episode, and sometimes it's stories are touching and sad like this one.
This episode is amazing. Everyone has a funny moment in it.
Truly a sad episode for James and cacnea. I thought it was kind of nice to hear Make a Wish playing at the end. It made the ep so emotional.
It's good to see an episode where TR are actually working with AshnCo. instead of trying to steal Ash's Pikachu every chance they get.
I haven't seen enough episodes with Cacnea in them to really judge if i like him or not. I guess I'll never know now, will I?
I hope you successfully learn Drain Punch!
Claimed by me!
Gardenia finally got James's Cacnea.... She had set her eyes on Cacnea the very first day she saw it
This episode was ok... It was cool to see Gardenia again. It was great to see Drain Punch for the 1st time. It was disappointing to see James giveaway his Cacnea to Gardenia, for training. It was cool to see the Gang deciding to help TR in this episode for a change. It was great to see James become so emotional after giving away his Cacnea, showing how much he cared about it.
It's episodes like this that make me REALLY upset we've lost old TR in BW. Cacnea's farewell was masterful, and as soon as Chiisaki Mono started playing, I went "No...please no..." because I knew tears would follow. Beautifully done.
Very good James episode.
I'm just going to say that I don't care that Cacnea left.
Just rewatched this episode. It was great to see Gardenia again since she's one of my favourite Gym Leaders. I just love how obsessed and crazy in love she is with Cacnea...it's always funny to see.
I really liked how this was an episode in which Team Rocket did more than just try to steal Pikachu, it's a nice change of pace. It was great seeing James working hard with Cacnea in order to get it to master Drain Punch. I also liked how this episode showed how much James cared about Cacnea and how he realized that it was best to let Gardenia train it.
I'm not a very emotional person, so I didn't feel overly sad about Cacnea's departure, but it was a bit of a bummer to see it go after so long. Though, it's good that it will become stronger with Gardenia.
~ * * ~
I absolutely loved seeing Gardenia return; her glomping James's Cacnea was so cute. I also liked that James teamed up with Gardenia to battle Ash and Dawn, but I screamed in rage when they lost. I thought it was nice of Ash to help make Cacnea stronger and I sobbed like an infant when James handed Cacnea's Poke Ball to Gardenia to be frank.
It's an odd episode. It's not particularly exciting. It's just Team Rocket and Ash and friends working together to try and teach Cacnea a new move. Nice to see them working together for once, but given everything that they done to him and Pikachu over the past four generations I'm surprised Ash was willing to help Team Rocket. Especially when helping them would potentially put Pikachu at risk of harm. I'm surprised that Dawn was the only one to say anything about this - We'd be helping someone who only wants to hurt us and will use the skills we help them acquire to take our Pokémon from us. Cacnea leaving wasn't that sad - At the end of the day both James and Cacnea had a choice and made their decision. Neither Ash nor Pikachu ever has a choice when Team Rocket kidnap Pikachu. If anything it's kind of ominous - Cacnea hasn't gone for good and if it ever comes back it will be a much more powerful and well trained Gym leader Pokémon. Which would cause big problems for Ash and his friends.
This is a story about Ash Ketchum and his loving partner Pikachu. These two share a bond far beyond that of ordinary pokemon and trainer. Together they pursue Ash's dream to be pokemon master and make friends with many different people and pokemon along the way. He and Pikachu train everyday to make this happen to fulfill their dream. But the path to victory is lined with danger. There are many challenges ahead for this couple. Ones that will make them see the world in a new light.