How would YOU change the banned/restricted list?

[cybermew]

If you were to want to make the game better for you, how would you change the list?

Here it is just for reference -

Forbidden
Black Luster Soldier - Envoy of the Beginning
Chaos Emperor Dragon - Envoy of the End
Cyber-Stein
Cyber Jar
Dark Magician of Chaos
Destiny Hero - Disc Commander
Fiber Jar
Magical Scientist
Magician of Faith
Makyura the Destructor
Sinister Serpent
Thousand-Eyes Restrict
Tribe-Infecting Virus
Tsukuyomi
Victory Dragon
Witch of the Black Forest
Yata-Garasu
Butterfly Dagger - Elma
Cathedral of Nobles
Change of Heart
Confiscation
Dark Hole
Delinquent Duo
Dimension Fusion
Graceful Charity
Harpie's Feather Duster
Last Will
Metamorphosis
Mirage of Nightmare
Painful Choice
Pot of Greed
Premature Burial
Raigeki
Snatch Steal
The Forceful Sentry
Call of the Haunted
Exchange of the Spirit
Imperial Order
Last Turn
Ring of Destruction
Sixth Sense
Time Seal

Limited

Breaker the Magical Warrior
Card Trooper
Cyber Dragon
D.D. Warrior Lady
Dandylion
Elemental Hero Stratos
Exodia the Forbidden One
Gorz the Emissary of Darkness
Left Arm of the Forbidden One
Left Leg of the Forbidden One
Neo-Spacian Grand Mole
Night Assailant
Marshmallon
Morphing Jar
Right Arm of the Forbidden One
Right Leg of the Forbidden One
Sangan
Snipe Hunter
Spirit Reaper
Treeborn Frog
Advanced Ritual Art
Brain Control
Card Destruction
Fissure
Future Fusion
Giant Trunade
Heavy Storm
Level Limit - Area B
Limiter Removal
Megamorph
Monster Gate
Monster Reborn
Mystical Space Typhoon
Overload Fusion
Reasoning
Scapegoat
Smashing Ground
Swords of Revealing Light
United We Stand
Ceasefire
Crush Card Virus
Gravity Bind
Return from the Different Dimension
Magic Cylinder
Mirror Force
Ojama Trio
The Transmigration Prophecy
Torrential Tribute
Trap Dustshoot
Wall of Revealing Light
Dark Armed Dragon*
Gladiator Beast Bestiari*
Plaguespreader Zombie*
Broniac, Dragon of Ice Boundary*
Goyo Guardian*
Mezuki*
Choas Sorcerer*
Card of Safe Return*
Reinforcements of the Army*
Emergency Teleport*

Semi-Limited
Mask of Darkness
Necroface
Judgment Dragon
Rescue Cat
Summon Priest
Foolish Burial
Magical Stone Excavation
Chain Strike
Destiny Hero - Malicious*
Green Baboon, Defender of the Forest*
Raiza the Storm Monarch*
Goblin Zombie*
Allure of Darkness*
Gold Sarcophagus*
Destiny Draw*
Mind Crush*
Ultimate Offering*

So, what is your choice.

And no one post "I'd ban everything nt in my deck."

[Raiburuto]

I would do the following:

New Forbidden:
Brionarc, Dragon of Ice Boundary
Dark Strike Fighter
Monster Reborn

New Limited:
Magician of Faith
Premature Burial
Call of the Haunted

New Semi-Limited:
Cyber Dragon
United We Stand

[DarkW]

This list is based on both what I kind of expect and partially what I'd like to see happen too. Seems like a weird list, but the list always has something unexpected on it.

Forbidden:
Nothing

Limited:
Dark Strike Fighter
Judgment Dragon
Magician of Faith
Pot of Greed
Mind Control

Semi Limited:
Mezuki
Skill Drain
X Saber Airbellum
Cold Wave

[Skater Trainer]

Forbidden:

Nothing is that broken yet

Limited:

Magical Scientist
Magician of Faith
Witch of the Black Forest
DSF
Rescue Cat
Mind Control

Semi-Limited:

Mezuki
Cold Wave
ROTA
DAD
E-Tele
Black whirlwind
Reasoning
Monster Gate

Unlimited:

Tsukuyomi

Tsukuyomi, does not need to be banned anymore, because we are in the syncro age, flip effects are too slow to be effective and tsukuyomi is not broken by any means. All stall cards need to be un-banned/limited because something needs to slow down this format of OTKs. Also to people who limited Airbellium or Gale, why? Did they limit krebons? No, because the tuner isn't broken, the way of getting them out is. Rescue cat is to airbellium, black whirlwind is to gale, and e-tele is to krebons.

[Kakashi-Sharingan Warrior]

Forbidden:
Emergency Teleport
Monster Reborn

Limit:
Ancient Fairy Dragon (Reading it's effect, it has potential to be abused)
Caius the Shadow Monarch
Call of the Haunted
Dark Strike Fighter

Semi-Limit:
Cyber Dragon
Reinforcements of the Army
Sea Koala

Remove:
None

[Clamps]

Forbidden:
Monster Reborn

Limited:
Call of the Haunted


I really just hate Monster Reborn. Mainly hate having my opponent kill a good monster with Mirror Force, etc., and then using Monster Reborn on it. It takes no skill, strategy, or planning. Very annoying.

[Raiburuto]

Limit:
Ancient Fairy Dragon (Reading it's effect, it has potential to be abused)

How so?

Also, I would like to know the reasoning behind people wanting DSF limited instead of banned.

[Kakashi-Sharingan Warrior]

How so?

Also, I would like to know the reasoning behind people wanting DSF limited instead of banned.

Use it's effect to summon tuners maybe? At the cost of a battle phase, it becomes an imperfect double summon that has enough defences to last a while on the field. Summon a monster, use AFD's effect to summon another, tune (maybe into another AFD)

speaking of which....can you use the effect of two of them in the same turn?

[Skater Trainer]

How so?

Also, I would like to know the reasoning behind people wanting DSF limited instead of banned.

Because he's not THAT broken, sure he contributes to OTKs, but he's good at 1, he speeds up the game.

Also I forgot, Chain Strike to unlimited, because Chain Burn decks are super cheap and crazy fast.

[Sapphiredragon929]

Eh, I say ban Plaguespreader Zombie. But it's limited now.

I just remembered my Harpies getting pummeled to near death because of the Zombie, but he's limited now so eh. I would say semi-limit Spirit Reaper. It's pretty easy to get rid of. Maybe semi-limit D-prison.

[~Sirnight~]

Cards don't just get limited/banned on how good they are. If a card gets too much play, it will get hit somehow.

Reborn is out because it's simple, and just a Normal Spell. Premature Burial is easily abusable because we have Arms Hole at three, and that happens to be getting a mass release via the Warrior/Gemini Structure Deck coming out.

Call is banned because it's a Trap. You can chain it to a lot of stuff, especially when it comes to having a Sangan or Card Trooper in your Grave, and targeting it with Call when your opponent uses Heavy Storm. Also, the Jinzo rulings make it quite unpopular around judges.

[cybermew]

How so?

Also, I would like to know the reasoning behind people wanting DSF limited instead of banned.

DSF isn't AS broke at one. It is still useful for OTKs, but doesn't cause the same problem as Double Priest, Cat, Double Airbellum, Double DSF.

However, it helps decks that shouldn't OTK, OTK.

If we banned everything that can cause OTKs, Batterymen would be dead. OTKs should be able to be used in every deck, or get rid of them all together.

[Freya]

Cards don't just get limited/banned on how good they are. If a card gets too much play, it will get hit somehow.

Reborn is out because it's simple, and just a Normal Spell. Premature Burial is easily abusable because we have Arms Hole at three, and that happens to be getting a mass release via the Warrior/Gemini Structure Deck coming out.

Call is banned because it's a Trap. You can chain it to a lot of stuff, especially when it comes to having a Sangan or Card Trooper in your Grave, and targeting it with Call when your opponent uses Heavy Storm. Also, the Jinzo rulings make it quite unpopular around judges.

Also Brionac(or any bouncer really) can bounce back Call and Burial for multiple uses(even though you lose what you originally summoned). WHY CANT THIS GAME JUST BE SIMPLE AGAIN WHEN I RAN RED MEDICINE AND HORN OF THE UNICORN. ;(

[minumranger]

banned
Brionac
Chimerathec over dragon
Dark strike
Rescue Cat

Limited
Cyber Twin Dragon
Magician Of Faith
Tribe Infecting Virus

Semi Limited
Black Whirlwind
Cyber Dragon
Emergency Teleport
Mezuki
Reasoning
Reinforcements of the army
Wall Of Revealing Light

Unlimited
Chain Strike
Future Fusion
Overload Fusion

[Freya]

banned
Brionac
Chimerathec over dragon
Dark strike
Rescue Cat

Limited
Cyber Twin Dragon
Magician Of Faith
Tribe Infecting Virus

Semi Limited
Black Whirlwind
Cyber Dragon
Emergency Teleport
Mezuki
Reasoning
Reinforcements of the army
Wall Of Revealing Light

Unlimited
Chain Strike
Future Fusion
Overload Fusion

Explain your reasoning between Cyber-Twin and Over Dragon, unless they are still destructive in today's meta(hint I havent played in 3 months) I see no reason for the their restriction/ban. Also reasoning behind unlimiting those 3 cards would be nice.

[cybermew]

Because he unbanned Future and Overload

[Short Wing]

Forbidden
Brionac

Limited
Rescue Cat
Magical Scientist
Dark Strike Fighter
Mind Control

Semi-Limited
Reinforcemets of the Army
Cyber Dragon
Future Fusion
Cold Wave
United We Stand

[~Sirnight~]

Also Brionac(or any bouncer really) can bounce back Call and Burial for multiple uses(even though you lose what you originally summoned). WHY CANT THIS GAME JUST BE SIMPLE AGAIN WHEN I RAN RED MEDICINE AND HORN OF THE UNICORN. ;(

Except in Kitty Brionac Synchro FTK Rescue Cat was in the Grave while Premature Burial stays out, so there's no real loss in it.

banned
Brionac
Chimerathec over dragon
Dark strike
Rescue Cat

Limited
Cyber Twin Dragon
Magician Of Faith
Tribe Infecting Virus

Semi Limited
Black Whirlwind
Cyber Dragon
Emergency Teleport
Mezuki
Reasoning
Reinforcements of the army
Wall Of Revealing Light

Unlimited
Chain Strike
Future Fusion
Overload Fusion

I don't even get this. Unbanned TIV is incredibly dangerous. That card is insane. Did you notice you you can use it more than once per turn? You just need a full hand to clear a field.

Forbidden
Brionac

Limited
Rescue Cat
Magical Scientist
Dark Strike Fighter
Mind Control

Semi-Limited
Reinforcemets of the Army
Cyber Dragon
Future Fusion
Cold Wave
United We Stand

This one isn't bad. Cat and DSF at one do control things well, and I really have no idea what Scientist would to to Advanced Format. I feel as though someone could still OTK with him, but the absence of Catapult Turtle makes me wonder.

Cyber and Future at 2 I disagree with. With 2 Gold Sarcs that can be run and still a pair of Cold Waves, the Chimeratech OTK becomes more possible. Even though not many people ever ran 3 Cold Waves though, but the same could be said for LaDD and others.

United We Stand gives Morphtronic decks a chance so cheers.

[cybermew]

I don't even get this. Unbanned TIV is incredibly dangerous. That card is insane. Did you notice you you can use it more than once per turn? You just need a full hand to clear a field.



United We Stand gives Morphtronic decks a chance so cheers.

I get it. With future and overload unlimited, and Cydra at 2, Chimera and Twin are deadly. TIV ain't that bad, it's still a full hand for a clear field, but it does get rid of BWs.

Oh. United We Stand is legendary.

[Freya]

Oh yeah, how could I forget.

Unlimited:

ROTA

Thats the only change Id look foward to. : D