23rd September 2011, 2:16 AM
I liked this episode, my favorite part was at the end where Ritchie's Pikachu appeared.
20th February 2012, 3:38 PM
This was a sweet and romantic episode, Misty teasing Brock was awesome, Brock had a great role and Sparky is awesome. There aren't negative things about this nice episode, 8/10.
17th September 2012, 2:50 PM
I think this filler was nice - since the focus was laid on a more romantic synopsis. I also think this was another good prequel to the Lugia Arc that started right after this episode. There were probably a lot of fillers in the Whirl Arc, but definitely some of them were interesting.
30th September 2012, 1:53 PM
A nice filler episode, I thought Jenaro was a really cool guy, I really loved him. I thought it was sweet that he proposed to Ariene, but seeing Brock cry was heartbreaking. I laughed when Jenaro's Sandslash stepped on his foot when he was trying to propose. I also liked seeing Misty tease Brock about how Ariene is already in a relationship. I'm really glad that we found out a little more about the Silver Wing. Also nice cameo by Sparky at the end of the episode.
31st December 2012, 9:56 PM
I feel so bad for Brock sometimes. He never gets the girl. Well, it was a cute episode, that guy really cared for her. Misty was hilarious. I need her by my side in the real world. xDDD
20th August 2013, 9:25 PM
This episode was superb, omg, could that be Richie's Pikachu?
I am really enjoyign the Whirl Islands saga. I like the proposal storyline
Also I quite liked the Sandslash in this episode, I'm not usually overkeen on them but I liked this one.
27th August 2013, 7:56 AM
This was one of the most boring Johto filler episode in my opinion. Ash, Misty and Brock meets a girl named Ariene, who takes them to her shop. Brock, as usual falls in love with her and holds her hand to show affection ...... but Misty drags him away. A guy named Jenaro likes her too, and he wants to give Ariene a silver wing pin as a gift for her birthday, but he's shy about doing it. But later, he maneges to give her the present and says what he wanted to say. They tells their feelings to each other and yet again, Brock gets heartbroken.
But at least this episode at least gave some backstory of the Whirl Islands and the legendary Pokémon Lugia, which was somewhat good. It's interesting when Richie's Pikachu(Sparky) appeared at the end, that was the only part that caught my attention in this episode.
5th June 2014, 10:40 AM
This episode was boring and predictable as there were nothing more other than Rocket tried to steal the silver badges then got blasted off. I am not sure why Leon appeared at the end but I am never a fan of Hiroshi and Leon. May be next episode can tell us more about that.
25th October 2014, 3:24 AM
I chuckled when Jenaro's Sandslash was stomping on his foot, as if to say "just say it, you idiot!!"
I was genuinely surprised when it turned out to be Sparky at the end of the episode.
3rd March 2016, 2:39 AM
Wow I liked how the Cotd guy here wanted to propose to the shopkeeper and the story of the Silver Wing's origin was intriguing. I liked how Ash's group ran into Sparky right at the end.
8th June 2016, 3:32 AM
Meh, at least we got info on the Silver Wing, but Ritchie's Pikachu appearing at the end was the only good moment.
13th November 2016, 11:55 PM
Aww, I thought Jenaro was a really cool guy. However, I didn't like Ariene much. I thought it was sweet that he proposed to her though and I laughed when Jenaro's Sandslash stepped on his foot when he was trying to propose.
9th January 2017, 5:31 AM
Shintaroo being a craftsman was interesting, as was his devotion to Yuriko. The fact that he worked so hard to restore her Silver Feather and then proposed to her was a tender moment, and I liked learning about the Silver Feather's history, too. Seeing Hiroshi's Pikachu at the end of the episode was a great finale.