Scariest Video Game

[zerothethird]

The original Resident Evil games and 999.

[NintendoCoke]

That whiteface game. *shudders*

[frogofdoom555]

Okami's not a scary game at all, but one thing that really stands out is the sunken ship. First off, the atmosphere suits the title. Plus, the ghosts don't stop moving when you use the celestial brush attack, the chests and pots can put out some freaky creatures, and there's a green hand following you around. It's a relatively creepy experience for what acts like a great game.

[PsychicPsycho]

Doom 3 freaked me out at the start, when I played it on the computer. However, I'm now playing it on 360 and it's not really bothered me at all.

FEAR was kind of freaky though, in spots.

That whiteface game. *shudders*

Hmm?...Oh yeah, that looks a little odd.

[SeekerofLight]

I'm sorry for bringing this up first, but I'm saying Slender.

Seriously, if you haven't already play it. With a friend.

Volume on max, one person walking and another looking. I tried it once with my mate, and he was looking so when I told him 'You'll die if you look at Slender Man too long' he decided it'll be best to walk around looking at the sky.

Safe to say... that keyboard sent us into little girl screaming fits.

[wingzx]

Probably amnesia the dark descent for me >.<

[Zoruagible]

The Left 4 Dead series. I always get scared when tanks come

[Night_Walker]

Dead Space II - scared the crap out of me, especially given how useless the weapons felt.

[PsychicPsycho]

The Left 4 Dead series. I always get scared when tanks come

I hated dealing with tanks, especially on expert (of course), although killing them was quite satisfying.

In general, I got a little scared anytime something approached with a special sound effect on expert (i.e., anything that wasn't zombies just standing around)

Dead Space II - scared the crap out of me, especially given how useless the weapons felt.

I found that game more disturbing then scary, especially the pack and those weird baby things. Also the 'eye poke' machine was pretty weird. The Ishimura level was legitimately scary though- so many bad memories and deaths, the tension was through the roof.

Which weapons did you use?

[Doux]

Silent Hill. I only played it once because of that. :(

[Night_Walker]

I found that game more disturbing then scary, especially the pack and those weird baby things. Also the 'eye poke' machine was pretty weird. The Ishimura level was legitimately scary though- so many bad memories and deaths, the tension was through the roof.

Which weapons did you use?

I certainly found it scary due to the combination of "what the heck is going on", jump-out scares, weird/frightening enemy designs and the general feeling of being weak.

Can't remember, been that long since I played it, but likely whatever weapons were there to be picked up.

[Thomas Elliot]

I don't enjoy getting scared or indulging in those kinds of things such as movies or video games.

But I did play Doom heavily as a kid. I blame Wolfenstein. It certainly had some scary moments. I remember being put in like this world where they have the giant chaingun demons and the walls are bleeding everywhere. Scared the heck out of me.

I downloaded Bioshock 2 and while I am sure it is not the most scary game out there, but it definitely has it suspenseful creepy moments.

[The Admiral]

Metroid: Other M. Especially terrifying because it's actually an official release.

[Un0va]

System Shock 2 is a pretty atmospheric game. The level with the cyborg maidens scared the shit out of me.

Metroid: Other M. Especially terrifying because it's actually an official release.

Resident Evil 6 was horrifying for the same reason.

[britishlanguage]

Horror games have never been my cup of tea, but I have been scared by the Dead Money DLC in Fallout: New Vegas. Although you could make this the background music in anything, and it would be scary. (Why'd someone bump a 3 year-old thread? Oh well.)

[PsychicPsycho]

I was watching some Doom vids on youtube when I noticed this thing talking about one of the many mods possibly being the scariest game ever. It's called Ghoul's Forest 3.

The video I watched is right here. It made me jump out of my skin more then once. Having it with sound heightens the experience, but the dude playing swears a lot.

Here's a video of someone playing the game successfully.

Also watched a video for Slender while I was there. I haven't played it, but I imagine I'd be freaking out constantly if I did.

[xerxes]

i haven't played it myself but i've watched my friends play dead space and it was absolutely ridiculous. .__.

[Kariris]

Slender Man scared me. Didn't played it, watched videos of it on Youtube. That's was a huge mistake.

[PsychicPsycho]

But I did play Doom heavily as a kid. I blame Wolfenstein. It certainly had some scary moments. I remember being put in like this world where they have the giant chaingun demons and the walls are bleeding everywhere. Scared the heck out of me.

I downloaded Bioshock 2 and while I am sure it is not the most scary game out there, but it definitely has it suspenseful creepy moments.

I read this comment before, and thought, 'meh, Bioshock isn't really scary'. However, I'm replaying the first one at the moment, and I've been reminded of Fort Folic. Those characters frozen in plaster were really creepy, especially...
    Spoiler:

Show Spoiler

 
when that one is frozen behind you when you turn around from the Power to the People machine. When I first played the game, I was like 'wait, was that there a second ago?' then it tried to kill me.
 

As for Doom 1/2 they could be pretty creepy, but the graphics were too bad for me to get too freaked out. Doom 3 gives you a bit of that (bleeding walls & weird scenary), but it's not that emersive. Delta Labs 4 is pretty wild looking though.

[Digipoke]

Amnesia: The Dark Descent, no contest, now where did I put my brown pants...

[Un0va]

There seems to be a disturbing lack of System Shock 2 in this thread.

Let's fix that.

[Snivyhero]

I've never played these two but Amnesia and Slender, people get so scared so much

[Hankka]

Never played many horror games but Amnesia takes the cake for me.

[Shayminlover123]

I find bioshock 2 really creepy for some reason.

[PSX_Cheatster]

Bioshock on Survivor mode-