Approved/Disapproved Games and Face-Offs

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Diplomacy - A Strategic War Simulation - Tamriel Map
Game Owner: Weakling
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Which of the two above images would win in a fight?
Game Owner: ElectricPokeLover
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Secret Story: La Maison des Secrets~...
Game Owner: GalladeofSpades
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Pokemon Mafia #1
Game Owner: Tumnus
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. There's not enough information about rules and gameplay here to constitute a game. It's not enough to say that it's like other mafias, you need to at least include the basic rules and set-up. In addition to that, considering how much time and effort thread owners generally put into the set-up and storylines of these things and the fact that there are only so many mafia slots available... I'm really not comfortable with letting something this bare-bones pass.

[Skiyomi]

Game Owner: New page New Topic
Game Owner: Tumnus
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. This is more of a discussion or chat thread, albiet one with a frequently changing topic, than an actual game.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Create your own Battle Frontier for Gen V
Game Owner: BGMaxie
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

Game Name: Apparently your left index finger has fired...
Game Owner: Ice Car
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. There's no interaction between players here and what people are being asked to come up with doesn't really require enough creativity or have a built-in structure to make up for that lack of interaction.

Game Name: Tic Tac Dough
Game Owner: Doctor Who
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Random Observations game
Game Owner: Trioxhydre
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Without some kind of organizing structure in place, I see this winding up as a quasi-chat thread.

Game Name: What Pokemon do you use against..
Game Owner: ElectricPokeLover
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Sale of the Century Week 2
Game Owner: Doctor Who
Approved/Disapproved: Approved since the old one is finished up.

[Dramatic Melody]

Game Name: Pokemon Safety Exercise: The Not A Movie
Game Owner: Sir DJ
Approved/Disapproved: Approved

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Count to Infinity
Game Owner: TherianForm
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. There's no point to it.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: [RATE] Location, Location, Location: When locations used to matter.
Game Owner: SS_Ａｐｐｅｎｄ
Approved/Disapproved: Approved since the last version was closed.

[Dramatic Melody]

Game Name: Catchphrase - Its the say what you see thread!
Game Owner: wongacat
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Leaving the creation of what should be guessed to next posters will make the game disorganized.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: The Sentence Game
Game Owner: wongacat
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. I'd totally say yes to this concept of game because The Telephone Game is inactive. But... on the other hand, this is a very sparse first post. I'd like to see some rules and perhaps examples. At the very least I'd like to see a starting sentence for people to actually play with.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Which of the two above locations would be a better hiding place?
Game Owner: ElectricPokeLover
Approved/Disapproved: Approved. I'm thinking there might be some difficulty with some of the less concrete locations people use... but I'm willing to let you guys try this and see how it works.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: What's your friend code team?
Game Owner: Shiny Rokon
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. There's no interaction between the players.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Im A Pokémon Get Me Out Of Here!
Game Owner: Im Da Waffle!
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. This is going to need a lot more information about the tasks and the gameplay, because this is sounding like a generic version of a lot of the competition-style games we have here.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Feebas used splash! It's not very effective.
Game Owner: Ryker
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Dramatic Melody]

Game Name: Feebas used splash' It's super effective!
Game Owner: Ryker
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. A similar game already exists.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Edit the sentence game
Game Owner: dragonite rules
Approved/Disapproved: Approved. Though I'd like it if you could make clear that making the sentence inappropriate or vulgar will not be allowed. That should go without saying, but sometimes people seem to need a reminder.

Game Name: Love or Hate game
Game Owner: dragonite rules
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: The Baton of Mystery
Game Owner: Wishing Star
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Too similar to the Ask a Stupid Question, Get a Stupid Answer game which is still active.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Share your worst jokes here
Game Owner: Street Comedy
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. There's no structure or interaction or ultimate goal here to really make this a game.

Game Name: The NeverEnding Adventure!
Game Owner: Ryker
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Too similar to this.

Game Name: Guess A Song By Its Lyrics!
Game Owner: Ryker
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Things get pretty messy when you have to rely on the person who originally posted the lyrics to come back and confirm that their lyrics were correctly guessed. Sometimes people just wind up posting and not coming back. Added to that, creating any real contest to this would be difficult since all the answers are easily google-able.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: Countdown
Game Owner: Doctor Who
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Dramatic Melody]

Game Name: Pokémon Universe Season 13: Roulette
Game Owner: Azran Flame
Approved/Disapproved: Approved.

[Skiyomi]

Game Owner: Say how the above poster will die
Game Owner: supersmew
Approved/Disapproved: Approved, but don't post anything that gets too graphic/inappropriate/personal.

[Skiyomi]

Game Name: The why game
Game Owner: giratina519
Approved/Disapproved: Disapproved. Why? Because it's basically a more limited and answerless version of the Ask a Stupid Question, Get a Stupid Answer game.