Rate the signature (Update to rules: 1/8/12)

[Toxic Nightshade]

Coyote_Dynamo: 6/10. I like the banner and userbar by themselves, but they clash colors when together.

[Blood Red Absol]

9/10 same as before

[DucksGoMooful]

9/10 ah so cute

[pokemongeof]

eh, 4 out of ten. very blan

[SmartD]

5/10
Bland.

[Coyote_Dynamo]

7/10 Watson

[SS_Ａｐｐｅｎｄ]

Professor Layton is nice. Credit could be linked, though. 8/10.

[Dragoniss]

Might as well. I updated it and the "hidden" music.

8/10. I like the colors. It really stands out. and omg someone that aligns left and not center

[ansem the wise]

meh its ok, 7/10

[Elysian]

A bit messy, still. But nice overall. 6/10

[Doodles]

At first the render didn't load for me, so I saw only the quote. While I'm not a fan of Assassin's Creed, I think AC characters make for good fan art. Your signature's a little tall, but it matches the text... I think. The grammar Nazi in me is annoyed with the incorrect stanza formatting and punctuation.

Anyways as I said before, the render and text do look nice together. 6/10

...

Also your username is awesome.

[Articuno_rocks]

Haha, I remember you.

Anyways, 9/10. It looks really pretty, but I can't understand the text (even though I'm Chinese. So embarrassing...). I don't really like the black bars, though, which is why I took off a point. But otherwise, great job.

[SpyroxPikachu]

8/10
I like the banner, but the text at the buttom seems unnecessary in a way?

[Doodles]

Ooo that banner really pops! I think there could've been more effort put into the bordering and maybe a different font choice, but it is really easy on the eyes. I like the well arranged use of buttons for links too. 9/10

[Dragoniss]

8/10. I like the banner, the colors go well with Sakura and I like how the text is reflecting. :3 Another simple but effective sig! Shououken! [I love playing as Sakura!]

[Elysian]

They're cute. 8/10

[ansem the wise]

never actually played creed but its still cool 8/10

[Gothic-Gothorita]

It's alright... I like the Arceus Userbar! =D XD 9/10

[SmartD]

8/10

The Banners are nice.

[Mister Man]

ansem the wise you're signature is really cool and thus I give it a 10/10!

[Doodles]

I think you should spoil your text, there's kind've a lot of it, and it throws off the banner. As for the banner... I don't like it personally because there are big rendering issues that make images look pasted. There is quite a lot going on, which is not necessarily a bad thing. And I say this only because I have the same issue: the text doesn't really match the signature, one part is grungy, and the other is formal with a drop shadow, which throws the rest off.

I'm sorry for being overly critical, and hopefully you manage to get one good thing out of what I have to say. It looks like the banner's yours, since I don't see any crediting, so trust me: there's only one direction to go, and that's up!

4/10

[Elysian]

Pretty and simple! 8/10

[Toxic Nightshade]

8/10 the character works well with the poem. It's nice.

[SmartD]

8/10

Nice.

[DizzyCobraMew]

Wait what? No idea what the heck that even is
5/10