Rate the signature (Update to rules: 1/8/12)

[Manaphione123]

10/10 Again...

[Shiny Glameow]

9/10

Time to change my sig I think...

[Plat. Frontier]

2/10.

Not a Bleach fan (anymore).

[Winamp]

6/10.

I'm sorry bb, but its too dark. The colours would be nice if it wasn't. Its confusing because I don't know if you want the smoke to stand out, or if you haven't blended it well ;-;

The light is obviously supposed to be sticking out... are you slacking? fight me pls.

[Zozo1999]

The Background is too Dark, IMO 5/10

[Toobworm]

8/10 osha osha osha osha.....OSHA OSHA OSHA!

[Mr. Joker]

I like the banner, but the text on the banner looks.. odd? I don't know how else to put it. I am big on the text formatting to the banners width, so I think that it may look better if "You are warmly invited to the Magikarp Group" was formatted to fit the banner's width and was on the line right below the banner. "The great person who made my sig put a link to her profile in my banner, so if you guys like what you see, click my banner!" is really unneeded, to be honest. I hate the smilies in general, but that's just me. 6/10

This is just my opinion, I really like your sig though! v:

[Northern Lights]

10/10 always loved that sig

[Toobworm]

umm....nice arcanine sig thing? 7/10

EDIT: 8/10 for the pretty banner!

[Shiny Glameow]

7/10

Magikarp are awesome.
As is Pizza.

[Toobworm]

9/10 Umm....Uryu(?) Is my favorite bleach character!

[Skiyomi]

4/10 - I like how Sunkern and Magikarp are placed together, but the rest of the banner looks low-quality.

[Giggity...]

7/10

Funny, but nothing special in terms of graphics.

And Winamp, it still doesnt look right- smarten up boi.

[Shiny Glameow]

8/10

10char.

[Hermosa Caldera]

7/10.

Even though it's only a simple image, Ishida is one of my favourite characters. :]

[Shiny Glameow]

5.5/10

I can't really read what it says...
Graphic Contest 2011?


Ishida is kick ***. >=)

[Hermosa Caldera]

7,1/10

Ishida becomes greater every second.

Click it. CLICK IT.... yeah it's "Graphic Contest 2011".

More shameless advertising.

[Zozo1999]

EDIT Ninja

6/10 It's nice, but really hard to read with the Skin I'm using

[Shiny Glameow]

7,1/10

Ishida becomes greater every second.

Click it. CLICK IT.... yeah it's "Graphic Contest 2011".

More shameless advertising.

I would join but...
I'm pretty bad at anything like that.

@Zozo1999 :
8/10

[Zozo1999]

I'm pretty bad at anything like that.

Eh. Me Too. I mean, I made Toobworm's banner, and it turned out awful. I was just playing around in GIMP.

2/10 It's a low-quality Screenshot that breaks sig rules :/