
Originally Posted by
AlphapupQuicksilver
> Twilight
> Sci-fi
> Twilight
> Sci-fi
> Twilight
> Sci-fi
*suddenly, many geeks fall over from cardiac arrest, Kairne included*
Twilight's not sci-fi, hun. It's fantasy through and through. In fact, the whole story is Meyer's fantasy wish fulfillment. I do wonder if her husband has read it, though. Because if he has not, he should. And if he has, I am not sure how they are not divorced. It's obvious by her writing that she has literally fallen in love with Edward Cullen, far more than she could ever connect to a real person. A couple-few theories:
1) Edward represents her ideal man, her obviously having skewed perceptions of what is and is not healthy in a relationship.
2) Edward's original characterization was drawn from her husband, and the additions made to his characterization after, that is, the abusive, controlling, obsessive side, represent who she wants her husband to become. More moral dissonance.
3) Edward is, in fact, her husband, down to every passive-aggressive, overbearing, over-controlling, abusive detail. his caged bird sings, not to be set free, but because she sees it all as romantic. Possibly she hated it at first, but developed a mix between battered wife and Stockholm. Bella herself may or may not have Stockholm (context seems fairly compatible with that)
4) Same as above, with one difference: she sings not of joy, but so some may see her struggle and help. The baby in the final installment represents the principle of family that her religious background will not allow her to actively seek sanctuary from her abusive boyfriend. Possibly, even, Edward is even less domineering, and so she seeks solace in the one safe place for her, her books.
Now, I have spoken a lot about the Edward/Isabella relationship, and how just plain wrong it is. I, myself, am in a type of relationship that does indeed have a set power dynamic. And yet, I find Edward's abuse of Bella's trust and her wishes truly despicable.