Black2/Heart Gold/X Trainer Card:
- Name- Dale Hudson
- Status- Rushing to Prof. Sycamore’s lab after hearing that Cheren sent all of my pokémon there after the Aspertia Academy was attacked
- Idols- Tucker Satoshi, Red, Cynthia, Alder, Lance
- Hometown- Aspertia City, Unova, USA
- Graduated from- Aspertia Academy
I liked this episode, Robert was an interesting COTD!
Best part of the episode for me;
"Don't tell me ... you're a photo sommelier?"
You know why I love this episode? Robert actually interacted with Ash in a funny and totally not robotic way. Plus he showed some realistic emotions that actually had me care about what happens to him. I miss having COTD's like this. And the ending was cute too (hooray for no walking-in-the-sunset). Somehow the way he only got a foggy picture out of it which only he (and maybe Ash) could understand was a unique idea from the writers.
I call Dent not being a photo Sommelier totally shocking.
I was wondering on the lack of Iris/Dent throughout the episodes but the ten minute - one day lapse at the end explained everything.
I agree with the pokemon usage thing. But really. The point of this episode was to be an emotional showcase of a photographer and the Sawsbuck. Your version isn't even this episode anymore, but more rather a rant about how you want all episodes of pokemon to have no COTDs (le gasp) and only pokemon. This episode not being what you want has nothing to do with the competence of the writers. There's more to a plot than how many pokemon show up yet that's all you ever talk about.Originally Posted by dman_dustin
We're not bashing your personality. It's called debating, even if you think you're standing on the side with less people.
* Credit to pokefan#493
Something that i loved is that they played "Emotion" while looking at Robert's Grandfather's photo album.
The episode was a little odd, in the fact that apparently Ash and Robert weren't separated from Iris and Cilan for very long(Apparently only 10 minutes), not sure what the deal with that is...must be something in that fog or something.
I thought the episode was enjoyable. It was more of an adventurous episode over comedic, which is a nice change.
3DS Friend Code: 3153-4608-8374
Friend Safari: Steel(Ferroseed, Forretress, and Bronzong)
Look I'm sure if the writers actually put effort into Ash's Pokemon, let's include Iris's and Cilan's Pokemon. I'm sure CoTD only episodes are perfectly fine. When they continue to deprive said Pokemon for other "more important" Pokemon or fill up episodes with crap that some people might not enjoy (Pokemon included or not), CoTD only episodes are really irritating.
It's like in order for the writers to focus on the non important Pokemon it can only be in a non-filler episode, and yet whenever it is a filler episode, instead of creating episodes similar to the episode Oshawott mastered Aqua Jet (excluding all the non-filler stuff) they decide to just decide to an episode just for the hell of it without any real consequence.
I'm sure this episode has its fans, and I'm sure some people like it but it doesn't have any value which would make people want to re-watch it again?
There's no way I would be like "Oh yes it's been years since I saw that Sawsbuck episode with that one photographer, I want to see it again." This episode is like candy, sure it might be interesting the first time, but afterwards its just a candy wrapper.
However if we were to inject a scene where Ash's Swadloon got to kick some rear end, or maybe Tranquill, <insert any other shafted Pokemon here> and I would rewatch this episode in a heartbeat just to see the scene where said Pokemon gets to have some awesome focus.
Just like Snivy and the Scraggy and Gothita episode, I might watch it for the Scraggy focus, but since Snivy was being a badass, I think I'd like to rewatch it just to see her kick Gothita's rear end.
This episode, just doesn't have that re-watch value that other episodes have. It isn't action enough, it isn't heartwarming enough, and it doesn't have very much comic relief in it, so why rewatch this episode.
This episode felt more like showcasing the Sawsbuck's forms just so they don't have to worry about the forms later on and showing that time is passing. Shame they couldn't throw the Deerling forms in there as well at least then it would've been more worth it.
Misinterpreting my posts is not your fault, negative repping me, and getting very sensitive about my posts because you misinterpreted my posts however is your fault. Think really hard, before negative repping or making a big deal about my posts. I don't appreciate being negative repped for reasons that are a result of misinterpreting my posts.
amazing episode!!! i cannot wait for the dubbed one in a hour
This was a wonderful episode rendition of Pokemon Snap; we get a character that reminds me easily of Todd Snap from the Pokemon Snap game and the the anime! This was a really neat episode. Especially with the history about the four Sawsbuck that reside in a single area.
Too bad Iris and Cilan were booted a lot from this episode, but it does add to the whole "possibly Inception" thing at the end. When they said "you were only gone 10 minutes" mystery.
Come on Nintendo, give us a Pokemon Snap 3DS game! This episode was easily teasing us for the demand of this game.
~I just wanna feel that rhythm~
Was anything said about the images of the previous regional Pokemon?
This episode was not neccessary. Another COTD would wants to hold yet another camera. First it was Trip, than Luke, now this guy. Is there anything else for these kids to be than anything to do with film?
Coolest Eevee evolution ever!
Ugh...why introduce a new character when the writers could have just brought Todd back? He's been absent for such a long time he would have had that "new character smell" for the new viewers. That would also have appeased the older viewers who would appreciate seeing him again.
Last edited by jolteonjak; 24th March 2012 at 10:37 PM.
Proposed Alpha Sapphire Team
It was an alright episode, but I wouldn't exactly watch it again. Just one of those ideas where the writers wanted all four seasons of Sawsbuck in one episode.
They have an idea for every episode.
Good ep one of the better BW ones. Had a AG feel to it.
Black FC: 5028 7872 0522 (Travis)
My shiny pokemon:
1 - It means the writers have 3 more formes to debut.
2 - This means fans will rage when Sawsbuck is the focus of more episodes.
3 - If all of the formes debuted throughout the BW saga, people would only be confused and annoyed at how it hasn't been a full year or hasn't shown the seasons properly etc. etc.
It was much easier to show all of the formes in a single episode as a special event/rare occasion, which the writers did perfectly.
i agree with the1stpkmnfan, todd should've made an appearance, that would've been cool, but the writers seem to be focused on new content and not thinking of bringing back old characters. and i was surprised when ash seemed like he didn't know what a pokemon photographer was. also i swear robert's grandfather is voiced by brock's 2nd voice actor, bill rogers. during the second flashback he definitely sounds like him.
trying to bring people the Pokemon they love and want
White FC: 1807 2764 2067
Not Currently Breeding
haven't been playing the game lately
*means that i have both dream world and regular versions
* * * * *
So the picture of sawsbuck robert took is kinda like the loss ness photo. wouldn't you say?
So is it summer time? or is it still spring?