Heart Gold VS. Soul Silver

[Shade2000]

yeah, which version do you prefer, HG or SS?
i personally would go with SS, because i got it first, and you can catch groudon. also i like the version exclusives

[Aquarelle]

HeartGold for me, since it's my "main" game of the two.
The original Gold version was also the first Pokemon game I owned, so it's more special to me than (Soul)Silver.

[telivisionhead]

I got soul silver because I liked Ho-oh better out of the two. But then I found out I could get Ho-oh at level 70 so I facepalmed myself. I really love Donphan,Phanpy,Growlithe and ARcanine though, If I had HG they'd be the stars of my team and never get booted off my team. Donphan would replace my Gravler and Arcanine could replace anything I dont use that much. But personally I've played soul silver to many times so I cant say HG is better. I really can't split them aside. Like cmon I love ninetales to (not the biggest fan of vulpix I like growlithe better) and I think teddursa is so cute and Ursaring was a tank for my team. So I can't split them aside

[GoldenGengar]

Heartgold cause my first was Gold the original. Plus I love Ho-Oh more than Lugia. Also like HG exclusives better.

[dragon user]

Hg because i bought it and becaus i had gold plus the exclusives are better

[OriginalPokeMasta]

Always liked gold more. The only reason to play silver is to get aeroblast with Lugia

[SuperEpicRock]

SS is my favorite, only because I like Lugia more than Ho-oh.

[Falconx03]

HeartGold because I always loved Gold back in the day. I am still confused as to why they switched some of the exclusives between the originals and the remakes like Teddiursa/Ursaring was in Gold but now SoulSilver.

[iloveicebeam]

i like heartgold better.

back in the day, i played silver version more, but i find heartgold more fun.

[Nibbles4Ever]

Soulsilver because lugia is the coolest.

[Aura Sensai]

Soulsilver,since you can catch a Vulpix,and you can't in Heartgold.

[ebevan91]

I picked HG because you get Kyogre, and I only had Ruby so I always ended up with Groudon.

[Necro101]

I like soul silver beter. Cause you can get Latios and Lugia earlier and tediursa.

RAWK ON

[Winter02]

I got Silver before Gold from the original games, and did therefore also get SoulSilver before HeartGold. But I still prefer HeartGold, even if I played it a lot less than SoulSilver. Not sure why, maybe it was because I didn't have as high expectations on HeartGold when I got it, which might have allowed me to enjoy it much more. And maybe also because Ho-oh had better battle music than Lugia in my opinion.

[TheBluePorygon]

SS, Lugia > Ho-oh IMO

[WastingLight]

HG because you can get Growlithe

[55afrothunder]

HG because gold is more valuable than silver

[Trinimaster.]

HG because gold is more valuable than silver

Best answer yet

[floatzel98]

Soul Silver for me. No real reason why i picked it over HG though.

[Elysian]

I only own HeartGold, but I hate it for not being able to meet Skarmory and Teddiursa