Heart Gold VS. Soul Silver

[Pierce571]

I would have to say Heart Gold because I simply like Ho-oh more than Lugia lol

[Bobby Soxer]

Soul Silver.. It and Silver were the only games where I got the second instead of the first.. (Fire Red, Ruby, etc)

[Fire Hero]

SoulSilver.

I remember when a colleague ordered Gold from the US. Then I decided to order Silver just to be different (and because I like the silver colour more than the golden one). It was the best Pokémon game I've played, or at least the one I enjoyed the most. So I had to come back for SoulSilver ^^

PS: HeartGold was the only main Pokémon game I haven't bought. My sister used to own the alternative version but she stopped playing and I though it'd be useless to buy both since they were remakes and I had DPPt already.

[MallorylovesVulpix]

SoulSilver. Definitely. I prefer Lugia to Ho-Oh, I think Lugia is so beautiful and elegant. I mean, Ho-Oh is pretty rad too, I just don't like him as much. Also, in terms of actual metallics...I think silver is a much more beautiful metal. So I'm partial to it. And the cannon name of your rival is Silver...and also, I think the Lugia figurine that came with the game was a lot cooler than the Ho-Oh figurine.

[Focus Aipom]

I always liked Lugia and exclusive Pokemon available in Pokemon Silver. I also loved the box art of the original game in comparison to Gold.

Same thing applies in the remakes as well.

[Mera]

But you can get both Lugia and Ho-oh in both games. I only have Soulsilver, but it's great.

[Neoqueenhoneybee]

Ha ha ha, I was going to go with Heart Gold, then someone told me that the Pokemon only follow you in Soul Silver. So I ended up going with SS.

I played and loved Crystal, so either HG or SS would have worked for me.

[PopPrincess_Lyra]

SOulSilver coz I like Lugia more than Ho-Oh, plus Meowth can be caught in SS.

Also that SS is the shippy name for Lyra/Silver ;P

That's why I own TWO SS's, nya~

[Wolveram]

I have both, but I voted HeartGold just because I like Ho-Oh way better, and I wanted to catch it first.

[pug6666]

Soul silver the version exclusives are better save for Mantine tied with Skymory.

[Coyote_Dynamo]

I've owned both, but I only have HG now, I might prefer HG over SS only because of Latias.

[mephistopheles.]

soulsilver because i prefer the box art.

[pug6666]

I also like silver better than gold in terms of the color.

[Exeggudork]

plus Meowth can be caught in SS.

this.

but then again i like ho-oh's design better than lugia's
so i'm not sure

[Ropav]

I like them both the same but if I had to choose I would pick SS because I like the version exclusives better.

[Nephilim]

When I came back to Pokemon, I only had Soul Silver at the nearest WalMart so I went with that one of course. Looking back on the exclusives, HG might be a little better but I've had too many good memories with the original silver and I still love Lugia more so than Ho-Oh

[Mystical Jackal]

HeartGold because Ho-oh and the exclusive Pokémons.

[paperchainchomp]

soul silver. but a remake of crystal (wont happen) would beat both

[Fleiding]

SoulSilver. I had Gold in de good old days, so this time I wanted the other version. Also because I like Lugia a little more than Ho-Oh, but unfortunately you can not catch Growlithe in SS...

[*~Silver*~]

SoulSilver. I just like Lugia better than Ho-Oh. xD