Espeon Vs Umbreon

[Navarch]

I like both equally. Both design and battle wise.

[Thomas Elliot]

Umbreon. Ever since I saw it coming in Gen II, even with the other evolutionary options. I've always tried to have it on my team, no matter the gen.

I just wish that it was more useful in competition.

[Epic-Inferno]

I prefer Espeon, mainly because I prefer offensive Pokemon to defensive Pokemon, and because I just like Espeon's design more. But, if the two were to battle, Umbreon would win, no contest.

[*~Silver*~]

Umbreon is my favorite Eevee evolution... I feel like it's stronger, and I like those Dark Types. xD

[Dragontail]

I like support, and don't usually lean towards defense, so Espeon!

[The Flash]

Umbreon has a cooler design with the yellow rings.

Espeon I like because he is an attacker. While Umbreon is more of a wall.

By far though the best Eevee evolutions we got so far. The grass and ice ones were, disappointing in design.

Still waiting on a sweet Ground, Ghost, or Flying Eevee.

[Jacobthepokemonfreak]

Neither, my Jolteon could beat both!

[Youngster Sheba]

Umbreon has my vote. Dat D-fence sahn!

[Greatemboar]

Umbreon it has the type advantage and immunity to espeon

[YellowHat's Revenge]

Espeon is the superior offensive player, which is what I prefer to have on my team. It's also much faster than Umbreon.
In terms of the 3rd gen, I always found Espeon to be more useful in the one Gen III game in which I used it, which was Colosseum.

[Gothic-Gothorita]

I prefer Espeon because of it's learnset and design. =P That, and it reminds me of Caius Ballad from Final Fantasy XIII-2, Kain Highwind from Final Fantasy IV, and it's my 2nd favorite Eeveelution. Tied with Flareon.

[Mitzi]

On technical terms, Umbreon beats Espeon hands down. There's no competition there, really. However, design wise and overall appeal, I would go with Espeon. Heck, for a long time Espeon was my favorite Eeveelution.

[ShinyUmbreon189]

I like them both but Umbreon has Espeon beat because Espeon won't cause too much harm, a couple Faint Attacks or even one it's over for Espeon. Umbreon may have low attack but Espeon has low def. Espeons a sweeper but Umbreon's a staller. It depends on what your wanting in your team.

[Chriiis]

Umbreon. Ever since I saw it coming in Gen II, even with the other evolutionary options. I've always tried to have it on my team, no matter the gen.

Umbreon is my favorite Eevee evolution... I feel like it's stronger, and I like those Dark Types. xD

These. It's also my favorite design of all of the evolutions to date and my defensive choice.

[Fallen Icarus]

Espeon. Its an amazing attacking, and Umbreon, while defensive can't do anything that hurts.

Plus Espeon looks better

[Hankka]

Umbreon. Easily. It's one of my favorite Pokemon of all time.

[Azimuth1011]

I prefer both of them equally.

[PaddysTurtwigFanClub]

I love them both equally. Umbreon is easily in my top 20 pokemon ever, but i couldnt say i didnt like Espeon on too. I love the way they are opposites, eevee maximum happiness at night/maximum happiness at day. Highest stat sp.atk and sp.def. Etc.
They are my two favorite eeveelutions.

[lake12]

I love them both... But Umbreon is just... Weak imo he just cannot stand his ground against over Pokemon....

[spyrosgost]

Espeon cause its offensive pokemon..now the umbreon is for wi fi battle because with yawn and mean look you can win easily

[TheSilentBang]

Id say both equally!

[ashiemore]

Umbreon is one of my favorite Pokés even though I like psychic types a lot. I would probably have to go with Umbreon in the end.

~ashiemore

[PKMNNINJA]

umbreon all the way.

[Greekboy]

I like Umbreon a bit more, but Espeon's cool too.

I was surprised the vote was so close, since usually people worship Umbreon and leave Espeon out in the dust..

[supersmew]

Espeon, maybe it's just because Espeon was a solid member in my White 2 team but I just adore Espeon and feel Umbreon gets all the love. Also, Espeons' design is beautiful.