if i had to number them then
It was disappointing. From Ash only having literally three consistently strong Pokemon, to some idiot who forgets his sixth Pokemon winning (2-0 pretty much) to there only being like two decent battles, (even the Indigo League had a few more entertaining battles) it was just not that great. They've had better Club tournaments.
However, it's over any now we can look forward to Episode N, which looks to be really promising.
The ONLY battle I liked in the Unova League was Ash vs Stephan.
As for just Pokémon match-ups for the rest of the matches, I also liked Hydreigon vs Pignite. But that's IT.
Kanto, I liked every single one of them (for the most part), EXCEPT Ash vs Ritchie. But since Ash got Top 16, in the most hideous way, I can agree Kanto was lesser than Unova.
Just my two cents
1) Johto - Johto had some unbelievable battles, such as the matches against Harrison and Jackson. On top of that, it did a great job balancing a narrative for the league with the battles. Even moreso, we got to see Gary and Ash finally clash in a showdown over 250 episodes in the making. Ash fought through 6 trainers before losing to Harrison, and placing in the top 8. Some of the show's best battles that made full use of the benefits of Anime Style battling, a good plot, and natural progression earn it the top spot for me.
2) Sinnoh - Sinnoh had many of the same strengths the Johto league did, though the overall plot wasn't as cohesive and fun as the Johto league episodes for me. The matches against Paul and Tobias in particular are still arguably Ash's best matches. For fantastic battles, long awaited Rival showdowns, and a decent narrarative, I award Sinnoh the number 2 spot.
3) Kanto - Ash's very first league showed just how much the series had progressed in 80 episodes. Sure the battles weren't epic the way they were in subsequent leagues, but up to that point, the only battle comparable to the league battles was the match against Blaine! More importantly, the league arc focused on Ash's development from a novice trainer to a competent one, as well as showcasing the bonds between his pokemon. It also was a big step foward to have him outplace Gary, his rival, and show he still had a long way to go through the character of Richie. The league ended with a promise of even better showings to come. Because I value narrarative over battle substance, I award Kanto the third spot.
4) Hoenn - Hoenn had good battles. In fact, most people remember this league as THE battle league. It earned points for having different battles, for Ash focusing on his Hoenn pokemon, and such. It's not a bad league at all. It's just that I found the other three to be more enjoyable. So Hoenn lands in at number 4
5) Orange Islands - It's not really fair, as it was still Pre-Johto and it was only one match, but Orange Islands league match was still pretty epic. It was Ash's first league win, his first 6 on 6 battle, etc.
6) Unova - So we all have our criticisms of this league. Therefore, let me start with the benefits. The matches were VERY well coreographed. I enjoyed seeing all the rivals have decent showings in the league. The match against Stephan was another one of Ash's really great league matches. I did think it was very ironic to see the Evolution=Win trope being used against Ash for once. Now the negatives. I don't think that having Ash and Trip's final rival match be a one on one with their Starters was a wise move. Even worse, Serperior goes down to ONE electro Ball? Then again, I've never been the biggest fan of electro ball, since I think it was silly for it to replace Volt Tackle, but whatever. Of course, having Cameron beat Ash was certainly disappointing, especially since Cameron seemed to be a bit of an airhead. Virgil being a red herring was something that was beyond lame. And of course, the WORST part is that they wasted a whole episode of the shortest league in HISTORY on AXEW. They also ripped that ending montage with ash running to Iris and Cilan STRAIGHT from the last episode of the Kanto league.
"I'm the best there is at what I do"
For give a official League order:
1. Johto; 2.Sinnoh; 3.Hoenn; 4.Unova; 5.Kanto
I rectify and put the Unova League better than Kanto ecause >I remember better than in Kanto through 3 episodes, the only battle was Ash vs Ritchie (that lkasted 4 minutes) and screenshots of Ritchie vs Assunta. Including the pats of the first three episode that aren't the League Deserves a 4, not more. Not only it's a letdown compared to other leagues but also it's a letdown compari9ng with other parts of the Best Wishes (BW had great arcs). The lack of at least one more battle and the first part of Ash vs Cameron dissapoint me.
I expected since the start that the league are going to be worse than Johto, Sinnoh and possibly Hoenn. But I don't expected that dissapointment of League. Then, what I expected from the league?
I expected that Ash gets Top 8 since the start. I'm surprised that Ash could get Top 4 because Ash was resetted in the start of Unova. And my outcome of the league has changed during the process.
-When Cameron was revealed:
Prelim 1 (1vs1), Prelim 2 (1vs1), 1/16 VS Cameron (3vs3 or 4vs4 Double), 1/8 VS Trip (6vs6) and 1/4 VS Bianca (6vs6). Trip or Bianca defeats Stephan.
-When Virgil was revealed:
Prelim 1 (1vs1), Prelim 2 (1vs1), 1/16 VS Bianca (same as above), 1/8 VS Trip (full) and 1/4 VS Virgil (full).
-When Ash vs TRip was confirmed to be in Round 1:
1st round VS Trip (3vs3)*, 1/16 VS Bianca (same as above, 1/8 VS Cameron (full) and 1/4 VS Virgil (full).
-When we know that Ash is facing Stephan and Kotetsu: The same as now but with Ash facing Virgil. I thought that Ash facing Virgil was confirmed.
-The final result:
Prelim. VS Trip (1vs1),1/8 VS Stephan and 1/4 VS Kotetsu.
And I give my prediction of the league when Ash vs Trip was announced:
-When Virgil was revealed.
Episode 1: Introduction.
Episode 2: Prelimaries
Episode 3: More preliminaries of the rest of rivals. Stephan vs Bianca.
Episode 4: Ash vs Bianca, Cameron vs Trip.
Episode 5: Ash vs Trip I
Episode 6: Ash vs Trip II
Episode 7: Ash vs Virgil (yes, only 1 episode)- Virgil wins.
In fact, the League has had 7 episodes when we consider that in leagues like Hoenn and Sinnoh, the battles doesn't started until a bit later in the second episode, giving 6 episodes (Hoenn) and 7 episodes (Sinnoh) of battles.
I remember the Unova compared eith past league and OI just remember that in Unova with the excpetion of the Axew plot, all the episode was almost dedicated to the League from start to finish. The only League that I remember something similar at the end was Hoenn and his three full battles (when in Unova we got 9, in Hoenn we got 18).
I think that the Sinnoh saga was too good. Until I know that BW was coming, I thought that Ash would win that league and start taking the Elite 4 members. And that the league will last like 11 episodes. And I thought that Dawn is really winning the GF AND that the Glameow episode was a "fake" episode made by OLM to hide the celebration party.
Last edited by Eievui-Nymphia; 10th January 2013 at 9:12 PM.
4.Unova and Kanto
My Final B2-normal mode- team:
Well I am sure he win the next league right RIght RIGHT?
The problem is Ritchie couldn't beat Ash had the battle been actually written well. It was obvious Ash was superior to Ash, and the only reason Ash lost was because Ash was a beginner.
Had the battle been written well, as in not devoted it's time to Team Rocket, maybe I wouldn't have a had a problem with it.
The thing that makes it worse is Ash almost got disqualified because of Team Rocket.
And because of Team Rocket, Ash was forced to use Charizard.
That battle can't even be called a battle, it was just a horrible rushed mess, that will always earn its place as the worst battle EVER.
Ash didn't even call out any attacks, that's how rushed it was. At least every other 'horrible' battle at least resembles and anime Pokémon battle.
I do agree that TR should not have interupted though, they shouldn't have been in the episode and at the very least could have been looking from afar. I'd have preferred the 3v3 drawn out over the episode instead of being rushed in the last 5 minutes. The quality of the Indigo League battles was awesome, so if the finale had been like the rest, i'm sure people wouldn't rage so much on Charizard disobeying Ash and costing him the battle.
Hoenn was the best and had some really good battles. There was more 6 vs 6 battles too, which I liked, and the CotDs didn't seem lifeless and created solely to be beaten. It also had the best handling of Ash's team.
Sinnoh was good but it had some relatively small issues. Skipping an entire battle, weird use of reserves (some appeared and weren't touched), Tobias having a Latios. Ash vs Paul is definitely the highlight that bumps it ahead of Johto.
Johto. I honestly can't remember it well. I liked the format and the final two battles.
Unova was a mess, but at least it had the fruits of Best Wishes, like... uh, good animation.
Kanto had nostalgic value, but the battles in retrospect were so crappy. The exposure of certain Pokemon was handled weirdly too.
Originally Posted by .
If any sport that existed that involved animals, and your animal was being kidnapped, I really don't think it's right to disqualify anyone for that.
Seeing as how that's an extreme extenuating circumstance, I understand that there is time factor, but for all anyone knew (I know this is for kids but still), Ash and Pikachu could've been lying somewhere dead or dying, and all anyone seemed to really care about was "No one's here battling Ritchie, oh well let's disqualify him and move on, we have better things to do." How about you pause the tournament and have everyone out looking for him. Seriously he's 10 years old. You don't just wait hours and hours hoping he shows up. Seriously that's one of the reasons I disliked the episode.
The battle however will always be the worst thing that happened to Pokémon, it can't even be called a battle. It's not like anything really fainted. Ritchie's Charmander only lost because it ran away from Charizard like a coward on top of falling asleep.
And Ritchie only won because Charizard refused to battle.
I've seen better rushed battles, that actually resemble battles.
The Unova league has to be the worst league by far.
First of all he fought Trip way to early. I think DP got it right with Paul. Also a mere 1 vs 1 with the main rival is just a stupid idea in my opinion.
The Axew filler was random and didn't make a lot sense either.
But Ash losing to Cameron was probably the worst. It's not only that he defeated Ash with only 5 Pokemon but it's also that he is the world's dumbest trainer.
Such a shame that Ash lost to a guy like that.
Virgil is probably the only thing I liked about this league but other then that I am glad that it's over. The Don tournaments were probably even better then this.
Episode N looks promising and I am glad we can put this league behind us and forget about it.
For me it goes: Johto > Kanto > Hoenn > Sinnoh >>>>>>>>>> Unova. Like seriously, I cannot even begin to describe how many things were done wrong in the Unova League. I just feel that I wasted my time following it. I thought it would redeem some of the travesties that occurred during the rest of BW, but it ended up being the straw that broke the camel's back, for me anyway. I don't know how other people feel about it.
I would have to say that I think the handling of the Pokemon leagues have been deteriorating since the end of the Houen league. Skipping over matches is never a good thing in Pokemon leagues, this is one of the few times in the series that we see a series of Pokemon battles back to back to back. I also disliked having two on two battles instead of double battles or just skipping to three on three. I was actually fine with the one on one battles but only if none of the major rivals were eliminated.
Pros: First pokemon league; nice usage of Pokemon that were never used in battle before (Muk and Krabby/Kingler); character development for Gary; Ash losing and dedicating himself to try harder
Cons: Skipping over parts of battles; Team Rocket tiring out Pikachu and Pidgeotto before the last battle;
Pros: Detailed preliminary rounds, great rotation of Pokemon; 6 on 6 battle between Ash and Gary; Ash doing better than the previous league
Cons: Kingler missing out on battling
Pros: Detailed preliminary rounds; double battles; interesting choice to use only his Houen team; 3 six on six battles
Cons: Ash making stupid mistakes (Pikachu vs Steelix); no rivals until the league
Pros: Introducing an opponent with legenday Pokemon; six on six battles; Ash making it to the top 4
Cons: Skipping over the screening rounds straight to the preliminaries; having Tobias appear with 2 legendary Pokemon without making an appearance before the league; Skipping over one of Ash's preliminary battles despite skipping the entire screening round
Pros: Detailed preliminary rounds;
Cons: Only 1 six on six battle; skipping over matches; Ash making stupid mistakes (Pignite vs Swanna); eliminating Trip in the screening round; Ash placing worst than the last league
Hmm, it's not entirely possible to send a search team though. Ash could have been absolutely anywhere in the world which could have taken weeks/months to find him. The League battles needed to keep moving forward so it does seem like a standard procedure to disqualify the opponent if he doesn't show.How about you pause the tournament and have everyone out looking for him. Seriously he's 10 years old. You don't just wait hours and hours hoping he shows up. Seriously that's one of the reasons I disliked the episode.
I'm sure if we had a Football game about to begin and a player didn't show, the team would still carry on with another player making the replacement. No search team until after the game if at all.
Also, the fact that Ash is 10 years old travelling the world alone is much more drastic than missing a battle.
Alright, I can definetly see why you hate this battle so much but I did actually enjoy it for what it was. Squirtle and Pikachu vs Butterfree did exist, and Charmander vs Pikachu existed too. Just because of the Charizard incident didn't mean those two battles didn't take place. I do agree the battle (heck the episode) definetly could have been TONNES better, but it wasn't and i'm fine for what it was. As I said above, it would have been much better if TR didn't do anything and the whole episode was based on the 3v3, much like Ash vs Stephan. This way the battle could have been more effective and interesting, instead what we got was rushed which is a real shame.The battle however will always be the worst thing that happened to Pokémon, it can't even be called a battle. It's not like anything really fainted. Ritchie's Charmander only lost because it ran away from Charizard like a coward on top of falling asleep.
And Ritchie only won because Charizard refused to battle.
I've seen better rushed battles, that actually resemble battles.