And if unbuyable items start being sold (Ether)? Would you like? Why? Why not?

[Mystical Jackal]

Rare Candy and Ether are some of items that you cannot buy in the any game. They're quite precious and useful, though. As they aren't sold in any place, you have to think twice before using one. I would use my Ether usually in Elite Four, and in at the first time only. The Rare Candies I usually don't need, but in that case, I would use a Rare Candy if get stuck at an in-game battle (rival, gym leader, for example). The saddest part on using an unbuyable item is that you won't use another further when run out of them as they're limited. They'll be gone forever... So, here comes the question of the thread:

Would you like if some unbuyable items start to be available in shops? Which items could went on sale and which could still be limited? Why??? Do you think that if they went on sale, the game will become easier? It doesn't need to be in every blue-roof Market, but in special and unique shops, like the herbs. Also, I used Rare Candy and Ether as example, but you can mention other unbuyable items like Elixir, Old Gateau and White Herb.

Also, don't say that Pickup ability solves que Rare Candy issue. The chances of a Pokemon picking up a Rare Candy are extremely low to provide Rare Candies often.

[Bolt the Cat]

Rare Candies shouldn't be sold because it makes leveling up too easy.

I do think that Ether and all its variations should be sold, though, it's really annoying if you're out training or clearing a long dungeon and you're pretty much forced to return to a healing spot because you ran out of PP.

Also, PP Up should be sold as well. If you can buy Iron, Calcium, Carbos, HP Up and all that stuff there's no reason why you can't buy PP Up as well. Especially when you already have PP Max as a rare, unsellable item.

[Thunderstrike18]

I would like all those items to be sold in pokestores because,

First off, like you said they aren't infinite. And with the pickup ability, it's extremely low to find one. And if they started selling them at the stores it would solve all the problems.

Second off, They would have to be at a really high price so you would like buy 500 of them at a time.

Third, those items are rare for a reason, so they should only be available at some of the stores. If they were at all of the stores throughout the game, you would just be able to go into any of them and but them in like a crazy shopping spree.

And that's why I thought you should be able to buy them.

But, in other words they shouldn't be sold because it would be way to easy to level up your Pokemon through out the game.

So, it can go either way.

[ebevan91]

We should be able to buy a limited amount of ethers and elixirs. Maybe a few per badge or something like that.

[Feralninja]

*points to Join Avenue, where all of those things, or at least many things with the same properties, are for sale*

[Rakurai]

You already can buy ethers and PP Ups in B/W 2 from Join Avenue, just once a day.

[Excitable Boy]

PP Up can be bought via Join Avenue
Ethers can be bought via Join Avenue or found in the Dream World
Old Gateau can be bought via Join Avenue (even though in BW/2 its best usage is to sell to the maniac)
Rare Candy is buyable at Battle Subway/PWT, found in the Dream World, or farmed from Sports Dome Breeders in BW2
White Herb is buyable at Battle Subway/PWT, just like most of the one-off hold items
Elixirs can be found in the Dream World

The point of making the items unable to be purchased in normal shops is to make these other methods of obtaining them worthwhile. None of them are really necessary to the quest, so what's the harm?

The only items I'd like to see introduced to shops, probably shopping malls, would be PP Up/PP Max (for 14,400 and 43,200 yen, respectively; 50% more than the other steroids, so it's a fair price), because they're a pain to get in large quantities in Gen V, and elemental Stones (Fire, Water, Thunder, Leaf, for 2100 yen, their original price), since they were available for purchase in RBGYFRLG, and there's an even greater need for them in Gen V, what with all the new Pokemon that evolve with them, especially Water and Leaf.

[Jdrawer]

I say nay, for the simple fact that with enough time, you could be level 100 before Brock w/o any training. Well, I'd like to be able to buy Ethers, since I can buy Potions... But Rare Candies are kinda cheap; you don't get as many IVs/EVs, so why bother? I only use them if I need an HM slave to evolve or right before the E4.

[SoulMuse]

I would say a definite no to Rare Candies, cheapens things up to much.

That said, it would be nice to be able to buy Ether and the like, since it is really annoying to have to defeat 100 pokemon to EV train early on, and only have 40-50 PP. Just make things easier.

[Moonrox]

There's no reason, considering they're already available through other means.

I say nay, for the simple fact that with enough time, you could be level 100 before Brock w/o any training. Well, I'd like to be able to buy Ethers, since I can buy Potions... But Rare Candies are kinda cheap; you don't get as many IVs/EVs, so why bother? I only use them if I need an HM slave to evolve or right before the E4.

You obviously know nothing about competetive and just heard someone else say that.

[Mystical Jackal]

Rare Candies shouldn't be sold because it makes leveling up too easy.

I do think that Ether and all its variations should be sold, though, it's really annoying if you're out training or clearing a long dungeon and you're pretty much forced to return to a healing spot because you ran out of PP.

Also, PP Up should be sold as well. If you can buy Iron, Calcium, Carbos, HP Up and all that stuff there's no reason why you can't buy PP Up as well. Especially when you already have PP Max as a rare, unsellable item.

Rare Candies help the Pokemon level up, but don't help the Pokemon with the EV's. If the trainer forgets to trainer the Pokemon on the usual way (against other Pokemons), he/she will have a high Level Pokemon with low stats.

They would have to be at a really high price so you would like buy 500 of them at a time.

Third, those items are rare for a reason, so they should only be available at some of the stores. If they were at all of the stores throughout the game, you would just be able to go into any of them and but them in like a crazy shopping spree.

Yes, to maintain the difficult of the game Rare Candies should be very expensive. Therefore, you couldn't buy 500 at once, as you said. A fair price could be around $20,000 in my viewpoint. Oh, could you pay all that for just a candy? >.<

You already can buy ethers and PP Ups in B/W 2 from Join Avenue, just once a day.

I have started to play Black 2 recently, so I didn't know that some of the unbuyable items have become buyable. However, it seems it was put a barrier to buy them (just once a day, as you said). This is probably to prevent players to acquire high ammounts.

The only items I'd like to see introduced to shops, probably shopping malls, would be PP Up/PP Max (for 14,400 and 43,200 yen, respectively; 50% more than the other steroids, so it's a fair price), because they're a pain to get in large quantities in Gen V, and elemental Stones (Fire, Water, Thunder, Leaf, for 2100 yen, their original price), since they were available for purchase in RBGYFRLG, and there's an even greater need for them in Gen V, what with all the new Pokemon that evolve with them, especially Water and Leaf.

PP Up/PP Max are good suggestion. It is expected that they should be rather expensive because of their effect.

And about the elemental stones, I agree with you. Hope they come back for sales again soon.

[Rakurai]

The value of Rare Candy has diminished considerably thanks to the level up services at Join Avenue (Which cost 4500 per level at max discount), the breeder in the sports domes giving you one every single time you battle them (Which can be repeated indefinitely), and the massive amounts of EXP you can obtain from the Chansey and Blissey in White Treehollow.

PP ups have also gotten even more common due to being able to receive four Star Pieces whenever you film a movie with maximum earnings at Pokestar Studios.

[Bolt the Cat]

But, in other words they shouldn't be sold because it would be way to easy to level up your Pokemon through out the game.

So, it can go either way.

You balance that by making them rare or expensive.

PP Up can be bought via Join Avenue
Ethers can be bought via Join Avenue or found in the Dream World
Old Gateau can be bought via Join Avenue (even though in BW/2 its best usage is to sell to the maniac)
Rare Candy is buyable at Battle Subway/PWT, found in the Dream World, or farmed from Sports Dome Breeders in BW2
White Herb is buyable at Battle Subway/PWT, just like most of the one-off hold items
Elixirs can be found in the Dream World

I never really checked out Join Avenue, I'll have to take a look at the list. But I do think some of these should be sold outside Join Avenue.

The only items I'd like to see introduced to shops, probably shopping malls, would be PP Up/PP Max (for 14,400 and 43,200 yen, respectively; 50% more than the other steroids, so it's a fair price),

Why exactly does PP Up need to be more expensive than the others? It's not any more overpowered than boost your stats.

because they're a pain to get in large quantities in Gen V, and elemental Stones (Fire, Water, Thunder, Leaf, for 2100 yen, their original price), since they were available for purchase in RBGYFRLG, and there's an even greater need for them in Gen V, what with all the new Pokemon that evolve with them, especially Water and Leaf.

Either that or just make evolution items easier to obtain. They don't necessarily need to be sold. Although if they would be sold, I'd probably sell them through something like Join Avenue.

[Bulba the Great!]

While I feel many of the unobtainable items are too sacred to become common shop items, I would like to see elemental stones made available again like in Kanto; only with the hitch that they must be found in the wild first.

[Mystical Jackal]

Since TM's have become infinte in Gen V, I've gathered a lot of money and got nowhere to spend it quickly. As we don't need to worry anymore to buy 3 Ice Beam at Game Corner, for example, introducing rare items to shops were a good way to make people still looking for money as these limited items were supposed to be expensive if they were for sale.

[EonDragonFTW]

They should sell rare candies, but only after you best the Pokemon league a second time and for a super high price

[ToeyJoey]

I don't use items, I hoard them, so it would be of little consequence to me.

[Excitable Boy]

Yes, to maintain the difficult of the game Rare Candies should be very expensive. Therefore, you couldn't buy 500 at once, as you said. A fair price could be around $20,000 in my viewpoint. Oh, could you pay all that for just a candy? >.<

If you go by the values of the items in the PWT, Rare Candies are worth 24 times as much as steroids. So, logically, they should sell for 235,200 yen.

If you go by the values of the items in the Battle Frontier, Rare Candies are worth 48 times as much as steroids. So, logically, they should sell for 470,400 yen.

Why exactly does PP Up need to be more expensive than the others? It's not any more overpowered than boost your stats.

Can you earn extra PP by battling Pokemon and earning Exp.?

Since TM's have become infinte in Gen V, I've gathered a lot of money and got nowhere to spend it quickly. As we don't need to worry anymore to buy 3 Ice Beam at Game Corner, for example, introducing rare items to shops were a good way to make people still looking for money as these limited items were supposed to be expensive if they were for sale.

And you know that the price of TMs has risen drastically to compensate for the fact you only need one, right?

[GreatGonzales]

Depends on the item. PP-replenishing items such as ether and elixir should be sold. (Why aren't they?) They aren't "too good", or cheating material or anything of that nature. They're useful, especially while facing the pokemon league.

TMs should stay the same. Some can be bought, most can't be. It creates a challenge and something to do. Rare candies shouldn't exist. Period. It literally defeats the purpose of the entire game.

[Rakurai]

I don't think getting your Pokemon to level 100 is the purpose of the game.