Wait when did Professor Oak get Ash's Charizard back??

[Crystal_Knight]

Wasn't the last time we saw Ash's Charizard was at the LAST Pokemon League tournament, when it came back to help Ash compete when he called that Charizard Valley place where Charizard was now living? After the tournament, didn't Charizard go back home to the valley afterwards? So how and when did Charizard come back permanently in order for Professor Oak to transfer him over to Ash when Ash called?

[CyberCubed]

Wasn't the last time we saw Ash's Charizard was at the LAST Pokemon League tournament, when it came back to help Ash compete when he called that Charizard Valley place where Charizard was now living? After the tournament, didn't Charizard go back home to the valley afterwards? So how and when did Charizard come back permanently in order for Professor Oak to transfer him over to Ash when Ash called?

What are you talking about? Charizard didn't appear in DP at all.

It's previous appearance was back in 2006 when it battled Brandon.

[wingzx]

it couldve easily been transported after it finished the charcific valley training

[I am Lu]

Shhhh.... The writers don't want us to question their plotholes.

[duh]

it couldve easily been transported after it finished the charcific valley training

The logical answer. /thread

That's pretty much what happened too.

[DawnBoy]

it couldve easily been transported after it finished the charcific valley training

It's pretty much this.

[Haunter227]

Apparently Oak mentions something about Liza during the phone call so it's guaranteed she sent it over at some point.

[lidaboy]

yeah i agree with the finishing training but can someon please tell me where you guys watch the raw episodes from?

[Pepsi_Plunge]

Apparently Oak mentions something about Liza during the phone call so it's guaranteed she sent it over at some point.

I don't get why we get into this discussion, I said in like weeks ago, that it either is at Oak or Liza sends it to him, I don't see how a place that Charizard from trainers stay to train doesn't have a way to transfer those Charizard.

I would prefer him to be at the lab, but its not like we get lab episodes nowadays.

[Cresselia92]

I don't get why we get into this discussion, I said in like weeks ago, that it either is at Oak or Liza sends it to him, I don't see how a place that Charizard from trainers stay to train doesn't have a way to transfer those Charizard.

I would prefer him to be at the lab, but its not like we get lab episodes nowadays.

Aren't those Charizard wild?

But I want an explanation of how Charizard arrived in Oak's lab. Just to know.

[pokemonsquared]

Some time between brandon and right now.

[Pepsi_Plunge]

Aren't those Charizard wild?

But I want an explanation of how Charizard arrived in Oak's lab. Just to know.

I'm not sure all of them are because Satoshi Charizard isn't.

I gave you the explanation in my post, it got transfered before and was in the lab already or he asked the girl to transfer him and then transfered it to SAtoshi.

[Joltik-Kid]

I don't get why we get into this discussion, I said in like weeks ago, that it either is at Oak or Liza sends it to him, I don't see how a place that Charizard from trainers stay to train doesn't have a way to transfer those Charizard.

I would prefer him to be at the lab, but its not like we get lab episodes nowadays.

There's a loophole though about Liza sending Charizard to Oak though, unless it means he's finished his training. The loophole being Ash was not originally gonna bring Charizard back until he saw that Charmander (and he had no clue about the festival). So unless Liza can now predict the future, there's no possible way she just sent Charizard to Oak without a purpose.

[wingzx]

There's a loophole though about Liza sending Charizard to Oak though, unless it means he's finished his training. The loophole being Ash was not originally gonna bring Charizard back until he saw that Charmander (and he had no clue about the festival). So unless Liza can now predict the future, there's no possible way she just sent Charizard to Oak without a purpose.

maybe she got tired of him beating up all the charizards she got rid of him by sending him to oak

[Darkrai619]

now the question is. Is Ash's Charizard the best Charizard of all time? Considering the fact Ash said I want my Charizard to be the best!!

[CyberCubed]

now the question is. Is Ash's Charizard the best Charizard of all time? Considering the fact Ash said I want my Charizard to be the best!!

No it is not.

[Haunter227]

I don't get why we get into this discussion, I said in like weeks ago, that it either is at Oak or Liza sends it to him, I don't see how a place that Charizard from trainers stay to train doesn't have a way to transfer those Charizard.

I would prefer him to be at the lab, but its not like we get lab episodes nowadays.

Tell me about it.

In all fairness, the whole scene trading Unfezant and Charizard is a misunderstanding and makes sense.

It's much more reasonable than half of the other ridiculous comments made on this forum, and trust me i've seen a lot recently.

[Cresselia92]

now the question is. Is Ash's Charizard the best Charizard of all time? Considering the fact Ash said I want my Charizard to be the best!!

No, he isn't. There will be always a better Charizard.

[blob]

Why didn't Ash get rid of Pignite instead of Unfezant? I mean, even Charizard as a Charmander had more battles than Unfezant! When's the next time we'll even see her? 2020? 2030? 2040?

[Master of Fire]

No it is not.

yes it is
your just a nay sayer