Starter Elimination!

[Colt45]

+1 Cyndaquil
-1 Chickorita

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 7
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 32
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 9
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 6
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[Pikafleg]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 8 +
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 32
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 9
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 5 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[shy_taillow]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 7 -
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33 +
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 9
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 5
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[Pikafleg]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 8 +
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 9
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 4 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[shy_taillow]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 7 -
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10 +
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 4
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[Pikafleg]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 8 +
Totodile- 13
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 3 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Well I guess if anyone is unsure whether I like cyndaquil I can direct them to this thread..... lol XD

[shy_taillow]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 7 -
Totodile- 14 +
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 3
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13


But there's nothing to like

[Pikafleg]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 8 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 9
Tepig- 2 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Says you! What do YOU know? :P lol

[shy_taillow]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 7
Cyndaquil- 7 -
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10 +
Tepig- 2
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13


Ummmmm, what happened to Bulbasaur?

[Colt45]

Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 6 -
Cyndaquil- 8 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 2
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

The same thing your tryong to do to Cyndaquil I suppose

BTW, Tailow is ugly as ****

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 6
Cyndaquil- 9 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Omg sorry that was me!!! lol quite a bit earlier in the page I guess I was highlighting the past list and missed the bulbasaur's line, sorry! lol ok so I put it back as it was then. My bad! (and btw as soon as you pointed it out I had a suspicion it was me who messed up, since I also hadn't noticed it getting low before ). And also, while I'm glad you like cyndaquil I don't think tailow sucks, I like it too and think its cute, and swellow is pretty cool too....could be partially because I've recently been watching the hoenn anime episodes, though (as you might have been able to guess from my signature ).

[Colt45]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 5 -
Cyndaquil- 10 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

cyndaquil shall thrive, Tailow (btw yes he is ugly )

Edit: I hate Swelllow more, if it makes you feel better

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 5
Cyndaquil- 11 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1 -
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1 -
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[shy_taillow]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 5
Cyndaquil- 9 -
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 10 +
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13


Taillow >>>>>>>> Cyndaquil.

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 5
Cyndaquil- 10 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9 -
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

2 users pro > 1 user against it, if you get my drift(loon) (:P)

[Colt45]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 4 -
Cyndaquil- 11 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 2
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

BRB

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 4
Cyndaquil- 12 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1 -
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[shy_taillow]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 4
Cyndaquil- 11 -
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 34 +
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

[Colt45]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 3 -
Cyndaquil- 12 (edit) +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 9
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Y u no liek mudkipz?

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 3
Cyndaquil- 13 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 8 -
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Nah mudkips are ok, just one of my least favorite of the starters (I really love starters though, including charizard and pikachu they make up 9 of my top ten favorite pokemon! (mudkip isn't one though). And why do you not like chikorita, it's adorable!

[Colt45]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 2 -
Cyndaquil- 14 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 8
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

i find it ugly actually, and I really thought it was annoying as a kid in the anime growing up, and I don't like how it ripped off Bulbasuar as a dinosaur just one generation later.. comeon at least wait two generations...

Anyway, what do you think about Squirtle?

Edit: also, how is that thing 87.5% male?

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 2
Cyndaquil- 15 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 7 -
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

Well if you don't like repetitiveness, I'm guessing you didn't like the 3peat of fire/fighting type starter evolutions? lol yeah that was annoying, hope fennekin doesn't turn out that way. Though you do have a point about the mostly male thing, it does seem like a female pokemon- in mystery dongen though you only get (or should I say "are") it if you say you're a female! And I already know that squirtle is your favorite pokemon saw it on your profile, but yeah I actually do like it quite a lot! It is like my 7th or 8th favorite pokemon. If you care, my top ten are pikachu, charizard, charmander (I would have been raising it to the skies here if I didn't have to rescue cyndaquil lol), totodile, aipom, cyndaquil, squirtle/bulbasaur (couldn't decide which one I like more), chikorita and piplup!

[Colt45]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 1 -
Cyndaquil- 16 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 7
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 13

No, that's fine, I definately do care, I always like hearing other people's opinions.

My top 10 would be: Squirtle, Electivire, Dialga, Bulbasaur, Sceptile, Umbreon, Salamence, Cyndaquil, Rotom, Braviary

Edit: actually, I didn't care about the 3peat too much, because I didn't really like Blaziken that much in the first place, so I didn't mind that they were ripping him off. It only gets on my nerves when it's something I care about. also, fighting is a lot more broad than dinosaurs, so it's not as big a ripoff

[OnceDone]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 1
Cyndaquil- 17 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 7
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
Tepig- 1
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 12 -

[Pikafleg]

Bulbasaur- 9
Charmander- 7
Squirtle- 14
Chikorita- 1
Cyndaquil- 18 +
Totodile- 14
Treecko- 11
Torchic- 33
Mudkip- 1
Chimchar- 7
Piplup- 10
Snivy- 10
The pig has been cooked-er um eliminated, yeah let's go with that lol :P
Oshawott- 10
Chespin- 9
Fennekin- 10
Froakie- 12

Thanks oncedone! And anyway, colt, cool, I love elekid's evolution line too, and sceptile! In fact, elekid is my favorite electric type to train and use in the games...because I can't deny how horrible pikachu's stats are, as much as I love the adorable little thing....sigh...oh but I also love jolteon (and eevee), since it is so quick. Although I hate to say but umbreon is my least favorite eeveelution, since it doesn't learn many good attacks (and in gen 2 and 3 there weren't even that many good dark type attacks at all).