
Originally Posted by
Chibi_Muffin
Hey!
I have to say, this looks like a decent story. Normally an Eevee would be an odd starter to choose from, but the Chosen One plot and the fact that a psychic, as opposed to a professor, gave it to her makes it make sense. The idea of a guardian of Johto sounds very interesting as well, particularily as it appears to be linked to being born on a leap year. Spinarak is also a good choice for her first caught Pokemon as its not what most people would think of.
However, your story is very short, and I think you could add more description and dialogue to change this. I'm not even sure if it meets the forum's minimum length. I'd recommend perhaps telling us a little more of what it means to be a guardian of Johto in the first place. Also, instead of describing the visit to Violet in a few sentences, I think it would be good to show Silverr visiting her and having a conversation, maybe about her upcoming journey and why she has been chosen, or indeed why she wants to talk to her, and then ending with her death actually shown for a bit longer, as this is a very important scene and I don't think you really did as much with it as you could. Finally, another opportunity for expansion lies in when she meets Eevee and goes into the forest, again you could perhaps show a conversation. I think describing the appearances of the locations, and characters can help you as well. Another thing you could describe is how actions and feelings happen or are felt; a jump could be graceful or clumsy, and nervousness could involve shivering or stuttering for example. Also remember to make sure that both your human and Pokemon characters have distinct personalities.
A couple more tips: try to split your text into paragraphs a bit more. You should go into a new paragraph if what is happening is at a different time, a different place, with a different person or a different action, as well as when someone else starts talking. Also, I don't know what you really mean by it taking place before Hoenn, Sinnoh and Unova as they are locations. If you mean that this takes place in the past and they don't know much about it, it should be clearer, as it isn't clear whether it takes place before the events of the games or if the characters just don't know about it.
Anyways, you have a very interesting idea here and I'd like to hear more of it. However, I would recommend working on describing your events in a lot more detail with more description and dialogue, and making your characters have a bit more personality. Good luck!