Quote Originally Posted by Joe
Because the writers thought she did. If in fact she did catch it.

Going by what you just said, Ash didn't really need Chikorita.
I didn't think he needed one, you're right. He shouldn't have gotten all the starters that season. That was the worst of all the seasons...

Quote Originally Posted by Serebii
May DID NOT get Arcanine
I'm happy once more! This really makes my day, thanks Serebii!